Snow Flower and the Secret Fan : Book Review

"Snow Flower and the Secret Fan" by Lisa See is a captivating historical novel that takes place in 19th century China and follows the lifelong friendship between two women, Lily and Snow Flower. The story is beautifully written, providing a deep understanding of the intricate social norms and expectations of women during that time.

This novel explores the painful tradition of foot binding, which was a practice in which women's feet were bound tightly to achieve a desired aesthetic. Lisa See delves into the consequences and ramifications of this tradition, shedding light on the power dynamics between men and women. Despite the constraints of their society, the novel showcases the profound connection and support that women were able to find in one another. Lily and Snow Flower, connected through secret writings on a fan, exemplify the strength and bond of their friendship.

A notable aspect of "Snow Flower and the Secret Fan" is the vivid and evocative descriptions of the cultural practices and settings. See's rich storytelling allows readers to fully immerse themselves in 19th century China, from the grand courtyards to the intimate women's chambers. The author seamlessly weaves together historical context and personal stories, creating a narrative that is both educational and emotionally resonant.

The characters in the novel are well-developed and multi-dimensional. Lily's journey of self-discovery and her striving for personal happiness amidst societal expectations is compelling and relatable. On the other hand, Snow Flower is portrayed as a tragic figure, burdened by her own secrets and regrets. The complex dynamic between the two women highlights the strength and vulnerability within female relationships.

Overall, "Snow Flower and the Secret Fan" is a beautifully written novel that explores the intricate nature of female relationships within the backdrop of historical China. Lisa See's attention to detail, compelling storytelling, and well-rounded characters make this book a must-read for anyone interested in history, female empowerment, and the enduring bonds of friendship.

What are readers saying?

"Snow Flower and the Secret Fan" received a range of reviews from readers on Goodreads, with the book generally earning high praise for its compelling storytelling, immersive depiction of Chinese culture, and depth of emotion. However, some readers did find the pacing to be slow and had difficulty connecting with the characters.

Numerous reviewers commended Lisa See for her exceptional ability to transport them to 19th-century China and provide a comprehensive understanding of its culture and traditions. The detailed descriptions of foot binding, the customs within women's chambers, and the significance of secret writing captivated readers and were hailed for their authenticity, offering an immersive experience.

The intricate and heartfelt relationships between the characters proved to be another standout aspect for readers. The bond between the two main characters, Snow Flower and Lily, fascinated readers, who were deeply moved by their unwavering loyalty and devotion to one another. The portrayal of female friendship within a patriarchal society struck a chord with many readers and sparked discussions surrounding gender roles and societal expectations.

However, a few readers did express their dissatisfaction with the book's slow-paced nature, which hindered their overall enjoyment. Some felt that the narrative dragged on at times, detracting from their ability to fully engage with the characters and the plot. They desired a faster-paced storyline that would have enhanced their reading experience.

Furthermore, while many readers formed a strong emotional connection with the characters, some found it challenging to establish a profound attachment. A handful of reviewers believed that the characters lacked depth and that their development throughout the story was insufficient, thus hindering their overall investment in the book.

#SnowFlowerAndTheSecretFan #HistoricalFiction #FemaleFriendship