So Far from God: The U.S. War With Mexico, 1846-1848 : Book Review

"So Far from God" by John S.D. Eisenhower is an immersive and meticulously researched account of the Mexican-American War, offering readers a deep dive into the intricate political, social, and military factors that shaped this significant conflict in American history.

Eisenhower begins by providing readers with a comprehensive historical backdrop, shedding light on the events and circumstances that led to the outbreak of the war, as well as the motivations of both the United States and Mexico. He analyzes the territorial ambitions of the United States, the disputed border between the two nations, and the escalating tensions that eventually set the stage for this war. The author masterfully dissects the strategies and decisions made by pivotal figures such as President Polk, General Santa Anna, and General Zachary Taylor, offering readers a profound understanding of the military campaigns and battles that defined the course of the war.

One of the standout qualities of this book lies in Eisenhower's ability to breathe life into the characters involved. Through vivid descriptions and captivating anecdotes, he provides readers with a rich and immersive portrayal of the individuals who played significant roles in the conflict. Whether he is unveiling the audacity of Santa Anna, highlighting the courageous leadership of Taylor, or showcasing the resilience of the Mexican people, Eisenhower crafts a nuanced and well-rounded representation of the key players on both sides.

Furthermore, Eisenhower fearlessly tackles the consequences and controversies surrounding the war. He delves into the political aftermath, exploring the intricacies of the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo and the resulting acquisition of Mexican territory by the United States. Additionally, he examines the far-reaching impact of the war on the Mexican people, the American soldiers, and the nation as a whole, providing readers with a comprehensive understanding of the lasting implications of this conflict.

In summary, "So Far from God" is an exceptional and extensively researched account of the Mexican-American War. Eisenhower's engaging writing style and in-depth analysis make this book a captivating read for both history enthusiasts and newcomers to the subject. It serves as an invaluable resource for anyone seeking a deeper understanding of this pivotal chapter in American history.

What are readers saying?

John S.D. Eisenhower's book, "So Far from God: The U.S. War With Mexico, 1846-1848," has garnered a mix of feedback from readers. The book delves into the history of the Mexican-American War, examining its impact on both the United States and Mexico.

Many readers admired Eisenhower's extensive research and accurate depiction of historical events. They found his account of the war to be comprehensive and well-written, offering valuable insights into the motives and actions of both countries. These positive reviewers praised his balanced perspective, acknowledging the complexities and controversies of the conflict. They recognized the book as an important historical resource shedding light on a somewhat overlooked period in American history.

However, some readers found the book lacking a captivating narrative. They felt that the writing style lacked engagement and failed to fully immerse them in the story. These reviewers expressed disappointment in the absence of personal anecdotes or intimate details that could have made the events more relatable. They also noted that the book heavily focused on military tactics and strategy, alienating readers with a general interest in history.

A common critique among reviewers was the overwhelming amount of information presented in the book. Some found it difficult to fully comprehend and appreciate the historical context due to this density. Additionally, a few reviewers desired more analysis and interpretation of the events, as well as their contemporary consequences. They felt that the book primarily presented facts without delving deeply into the impact of the war.

Overall, "So Far from God" by John S.D. Eisenhower is a well-researched and informative book that provides a comprehensive account of the Mexican-American War. While some readers appreciated the unbiased approach and historical accuracy, others found the writing style to be dry and overwhelming. If you are specifically interested in this time period and are willing to navigate through a dense amount of information, this book may serve as a valuable resource. However, if you prefer a more engaging and interpretive narrative, you might find it lacking in that regard.

SoFarFromGod BlessedByAngels MagicalRealism