So ist es gewesen : Book Review

"So ist es gewesen," written by Natalia Ginzburg, is a captivating novel that takes place in Italy during World War II. It revolves around the lives of the Levi family and offers a poignant portrayal of the complexities of the era and the fragile nature of human relationships.

The story is primarily told through the perspective of the family's youngest daughter, a perceptive and innocent child who gradually becomes conscious of the tensions and secrets within her family. Ginzburg skillfully weaves together themes of war, love, loss, and resilience, creating a deeply moving and thought-provoking tale.

One standout aspect of the novel is the author's ability to vividly depict the atmosphere of wartime Italy. The descriptions of bombed-out cities, rationing, and the constant fear of death serve as a haunting backdrop for the personal narratives of the characters. Ginzburg's exquisite prose allows readers to fully immerse themselves in this turbulent period.

Another strength of "So ist es gewesen" lies in its nuanced portrayal of the complexities of human relationships. Ginzburg delves into the intricate dynamics within the Levi family, exploring the bonds of love and loyalty as well as the strains and tensions that arise during times of crisis. The characters are realistically flawed and multi-dimensional, making their struggles and triumphs deeply relatable and compelling.

Overall, "So ist es gewesen" is a beautifully written and emotionally resonant novel that offers readers a window into Italy's experience during World War II. Natalia Ginzburg's masterful storytelling and her ability to capture the essence of the era make this book an engaging and worthwhile read. It serves as a testament to the enduring power of human resilience and the long-lasting impact of war on individuals and families.

What are readers saying?

Natalia Ginzburg's novel "So ist es gewesen" (published in English as "Happiness, As Such") has garnered a range of reviews from readers. Overall, the book has received positive feedback, with many reviewers praising Ginzburg's storytelling and her ability to capture complex human emotions.

Readers appreciate the simplicity and honesty of Ginzburg's writing style. They find her narrative genuine and relatable, allowing them to connect with the characters and their experiences. Reviewers frequently mention the powerful emotions evoked by the story, which lingers with them long after finishing the book.

Ginzburg is commended for tackling weighty themes with nuance and sensitivity. Her exploration of family dynamics, love, and personal choices adds depth and complexity to the story. Readers highly regard her ability to depict genuine human relationships, filled with both love and conflict.

Another aspect that resonates with reviewers is Ginzburg's portrayal of historical and political events. Set against the backdrop of Fascist Italy, the book delves into the impacts of war and political unrest on ordinary lives. Ginzburg seamlessly weaves these historical elements into the story, giving it a deeper context and highlighting the resilience of the characters.

However, some reviewers express concerns about the pacing of the book, finding it slow at times. They suggest condensing certain sections to maintain a more engaging reading experience. Additionally, a small number of readers mention that some characters could have been developed more, which affected their overall engagement with the story.

HistoricalFiction FamilySaga GermanLiterature