In his book, "Social Histories of Disability and Deformity," David M. Turner provides readers with a thorough exploration of the experiences and perceptions of individuals with disabilities throughout history. Turner's interdisciplinary approach, drawing from history, sociology, and disability studies, gives readers a comprehensive understanding of disability as it intersects with various social factors.
One strength of this book is the way Turner examines the intersectionality of disability with race, class, and gender, using historical examples and case studies to illustrate these complexities. By including these multiple dimensions of identity, Turner allows readers to see the intricate ways in which disability has been experienced and understood in different cultural and historical contexts.
Moreover, Turner delves into the power dynamics and social structures that have shaped disability narratives. He exposes how disabled individuals have been marginalized and oppressed, pathologized and discriminated against, and subjected to institutionalized forms of control. Through this analysis, Turner prompts readers to critically examine and challenge societal norms and attitudes towards disability.
Available on Audible
The accessibility of Turner's writing style is another commendable aspect of this book. Despite dealing with complex concepts, the author presents the information in a clear and organized manner, making it accessible to both academic and general readers. Additionally, the inclusion of visuals aids in the reader's understanding and immersion in the historical context.
Overall, "Social Histories of Disability and Deformity" is an invaluable resource for anyone interested in understanding the historical and social dynamics of disability. Turner's comprehensive analysis, interdisciplinary approach, and accessible writing style make this book a significant contribution to the field of disability studies. It encourages readers to reflect on the treatment of disabled individuals throughout history and inspires them to work towards a more inclusive and equitable future.
What are readers saying?
David M. Turner's book, "Social Histories of Disability and Deformity," has garnered varying reviews. Some readers praise its informative and well-researched content, while others find it lacking in depth or difficult to navigate.
One reviewer commends the book for its extensive coverage of the social history of disabilities and deformities. They appreciate Turner's exploration of various aspects, including societal responses, medical perspectives, and personal experiences. This reviewer considers the book a valuable resource for gaining a historical understanding of disability.
On the other hand, a different reader criticizes the book for its lack of depth. They believe Turner fails to provide in-depth analysis and overlooks important details. The reviewer observes that the book relies heavily on personal narratives and anecdotes, rather than offering a broader perspective.
Some readers also find the book challenging to follow. They note that its dense and academic writing style makes it difficult to fully engage with the material. Additionally, the organization of the chapters is criticized for feeling disjointed, with some topics appearing disconnected from others.
Despite these criticisms, other readers appreciate the book's attempt to cover a wide range of disabilities and deformities throughout history. They find the content informative and commend Turner for including lesser-known narratives and diverse perspectives. These readers feel that the book effectively illuminates the societal and cultural attitudes towards disability over time.
DisabilityHistory DeformityChronicles SocialHistories