Sources of Chinese Tradition: From 1600 Through the Twentieth Century : Book Review

"Sources of Chinese Tradition" by William Theodore de Bary is an extensive anthology that immerses readers in the diverse and vibrant cultural heritage of China. By exploring the philosophical, religious, and literary traditions of China, de Bary offers a comprehensive understanding of the historical and intellectual foundations that shape Chinese society.

One of the anthology's notable strengths is its meticulous organization. De Bary presents the material in chronological order, allowing readers to trace the evolution of Chinese thought from ancient times to the modern era. This approach enables readers to grasp the continuity and changes in Chinese intellectual history over the centuries. With the inclusion of primary sources such as philosophical texts, historical accounts, and literary works, the ideas and beliefs of the Chinese people are vividly brought to life.

Aside from delving into the major philosophical schools of China, such as Confucianism, Daoism, and Buddhism, the anthology also explores other significant aspects such as the role of women in society and the influence of foreign cultures on China. This comprehensive approach provides readers with a holistic view of Chinese civilization, offering a deeper appreciation for its complexity and diversity.

Furthermore, de Bary's insightful commentary and analysis throughout the book helps contextualize the primary sources and provides interpretations of their meaning. This not only enhances the readability of the anthology but also aids readers in understanding the significance of the ideas and concepts being discussed.

Overall, "Sources of Chinese Tradition" is an invaluable resource for those interested in Chinese culture, history, and philosophy. De Bary's meticulous compilation of primary sources, coupled with his expert commentary, makes this book an informative and engaging read. It serves as a gateway for readers to explore the profound intellectual heritage of China and gain a deeper understanding of its profound influence on the world.

What are readers saying?

The book "Sources of Chinese Tradition" authored by William Theodore de Bary has garnered a diverse range of reviews from readers. In general, the book has been widely praised for its comprehensive coverage and insightful exploration of Chinese history and culture. Many reviewers applaud its inclusion of a wide array of primary sources, which offer readers a firsthand look into the development of Chinese tradition over time.

One recurring theme in these reviews is the book's accessibility and its usefulness as a resource for both students and scholars. Readers find the organization of the book to be logical and appreciate the inclusion of various historical texts, which allows for a deep understanding of the subject matter. It is frequently cited as a valuable tool for individuals studying or teaching Chinese history, philosophy, or religion.

Another standout element highlighted by reviewers is the author's expertise and attention to detail. De Bary, a renowned scholar in East Asian studies, is highly commended for his extensive research and his engaging and informative presentation of the material. Many readers note that the book goes beyond mere translation, as it provides valuable commentary and analysis on the selected texts.

Some reviewers also appreciate the book's ability to challenge assumptions and stereotypes about China. They commend De Bary for showcasing the richness and diversity of Chinese thought, which provides readers with a deeper understanding of the complexities of Chinese culture.

However, a few reviewers express reservations about the book's focus. They mention that it tends to heavily concentrate on Confucianism while neglecting other important aspects of Chinese tradition, such as Daoism or Buddhism. While these reviewers generally acknowledge the difficulty of capturing the entirety of Chinese tradition in a single volume, they still hope for a more balanced representation.

ChineseTraditionSources ChineseCulture HistoricalReads