Speaking of Slavery: Color, Ethnicity, and Human Bondage in Italy : Book Review

"Speaking of Slavery" by Steven A. Epstein is a fascinating exploration of the complex and contentious history of slavery in America. The book delves into the many debates and discussions that surrounded this dark chapter in our nation's past, offering a thought-provoking analysis of various perspectives and arguments.

One of the key themes of the book is the role of language in both justifying and condemning the institution of slavery. Epstein meticulously examines speeches, letters, and other forms of communication from that time period, providing readers with a deeper understanding of the rhetoric employed by proponents and opponents of slavery.

Additionally, "Speaking of Slavery" highlights how the language used to discuss enslaved individuals reflected the power dynamics and hierarchies of the era. By analyzing the words and phrases used to describe slaves, Epstein contends that we can gain valuable insights into the prevailing attitudes and prejudices of the time.

What sets this book apart is its focus on the agency and resistance exhibited by enslaved individuals in shaping the discourse around slavery. Epstein amplifies the voices of those directly impacted by slavery, showcasing their acts of self-expression and communication. By doing so, he offers a more nuanced and comprehensive understanding of this dark chapter in American history.

Epstein's research is meticulous, and his writing is engaging. His analysis of speeches and writings from the period provides valuable insights into the historical context and allows readers to gain a deeper understanding of the perspectives of those involved.

What are readers saying?

Steven A. Epstein's book, "Speaking of Slavery," has received a range of reviews, with readers expressing both praise and criticism. The book explores the African and African American experience through historical documents and literary works, offering a comprehensive approach to the topic. Some reviewers appreciated Epstein's extensive research, which includes excerpts from speeches, letters, and narratives, as it provides a deep understanding of the subject matter and sheds light on a dark period of history.

On the other hand, some readers found fault with the book's organization and structure. They felt that Epstein did not provide enough analysis or context for the selected excerpts, resulting in a lack of a cohesive narrative. These critics suggested that the book may be better suited as a reference book or compilation rather than a standalone work.

A notable aspect that garnered praise was Epstein's inclusion of lesser-known sources, as it highlights voices often excluded from mainstream historical narratives. Reviewers appreciated the diverse perspectives presented in the book, as they contribute to a more nuanced understanding of the experiences of those who were enslaved.

However, some readers felt that the book lacked depth and critical engagement with the subject matter. They desired more interpretation and analysis of the texts presented in order to fully grasp their significance. These critics suggested that the book would benefit from additional guidance and discussion.

Overall, the reception of "Speaking of Slavery" has been mixed. While some praised its comprehensive approach and extensive research, others criticized its organization and lack of analysis. Despite the criticisms, many reviewers found the book to be an informative resource that sheds light on the African and African American experience during the era of slavery.

SpeakingOfSlavery SlaveNarratives BlackHistory