Sugar Cookie Murder : Book Review

"Sugar Cookie Murder" by Joanne Fluke is a delightful cozy mystery that combines the joys of baking, the festive spirit of Christmas, and a shocking murder that will keep readers on the edge of their seats. The story is set in the small town of Lake Eden, Minnesota, and follows Hannah Swensen, the owner of The Cookie Jar bakery. As the annual Christmas buffet approaches, Hannah finds herself drawn into investigating the murder of an unpopular new resident. Alongside her faithful cat, Moishe, and her two potential love interests, Norman and Mike, Hannah must uncover the truth before the killer strikes again.

Fluke's writing style is wonderfully engaging, with a perfect blend of humor and suspense. The cozy setting of Lake Eden during the holiday season creates a warm and festive atmosphere that immerses readers in the story. The mouth-watering descriptions of Hannah's delectable cookies and other baked treats will leave readers craving sweets with each page-turn. Additionally, the inclusion of delightful recipes at the end of each chapter adds a unique and interactive element to the book.

The characters in "Sugar Cookie Murder" are well-developed and lovable. Hannah is a relatable and endearing protagonist, driven by her passion for baking and her determination to solve crimes. Her interactions with her sister, Andrea, and her romantic interests, Norman and Mike, provide both romantic tension and moments of lightheartedness. The supporting cast of quirky townspeople, including Hannah's mother, Delores, and her best friend, Lisa, add depth and humor to the story.

The murder mystery in "Sugar Cookie Murder" is expertly crafted, with plenty of twists and turns to keep readers guessing until the very end. Clues are cleverly scattered throughout the narrative, inviting readers to play detective alongside Hannah. The gradual revelation of the motives behind the murder builds suspense and guarantees a satisfying resolution. The holiday theme adds an extra layer of intrigue and nostalgia to the mystery, making it even more captivating.

In conclusion, "Sugar Cookie Murder" is a delightful and entertaining cozy mystery that will captivate fans of the genre. Joanne Fluke's charming characters, delectable descriptions of baked goods, and puzzling murder mystery create a festive and engaging read. Whether you have a sweet tooth or simply enjoy a cozy mystery, this book is sure to leave you wanting more.

What are readers saying?

Joanne Fluke's book "Sugar Cookie Murder" has garnered a varied reception from readers. Opinions on the book are divided, with some finding it entertaining and engaging, while others feel it falls short in terms of plot and character development.

Many readers enjoyed the cozy mystery aspect of the book and praised Fluke for her ability to create a charming small-town setting. They found the story light-hearted and easy to read, making it a perfect choice for a relaxing read. Some readers particularly appreciated the inclusion of cookie recipes throughout the book, feeling that it added an extra touch to the story.

However, some reviewers were less impressed with "Sugar Cookie Murder." They found the plot predictable and lacking in suspense, claiming to have figured out the culprit early on. There were also complaints about the pacing, with certain parts of the story dragging and potential for tighter writing.

Character development also received criticism from some readers, claiming that the characters lacked depth and were one-dimensional. They expressed disappointment in the lack of growth or change in the main characters, which made it difficult for them to connect and empathize.

Despite these criticisms, there were still fans of Fluke's book who found it enjoyable. They appreciated the cozy atmosphere and considered it a good choice for a light mystery read. However, those seeking a more intricate and suspenseful plot may find "Sugar Cookie Murder" not meeting their expectations.

SugarCookieMurder CozyMystery BookClub