That Old Ace in the Hole : Book Review

Annie Proulx's novel, "That Old Ace in the Hole," takes readers on a captivating journey through the American Midwest. Set in the vast landscapes of the Texas panhandle, the story explores themes of identity, heritage, and the evolving landscape of America.

The protagonist, Bob Dollar, is a young man sent by his employer to assess potential sites for a large hog farm. As Dollar navigates the small town of Woolybucket, he becomes entangled in the lives of its diverse inhabitants and discovers the rich history that shapes the region.

Proulx's writing is both evocative and detailed, painting a vivid picture of the Texas panhandle and its unique charm. With skillful storytelling, the author weaves together multiple storylines and characters, creating a tapestry of interconnected lives and experiences. Through her descriptions, readers can almost feel the heat and dust of the Midwest environment.

One of the novel's strengths lies in its exploration of identity. As an outsider, Dollar grapples with his own sense of belonging as he immerses himself in the community's traditions and histories. Proulx delves into the complexities of heritage and how it shapes individual and collective identities. The characters in the story are deeply connected to their land, family histories, and the narratives that have shaped their lives.

Furthermore, Proulx examines the changing landscape of America and the impact of modernization on rural communities. Through the lens of the hog farming industry, she highlights the tension between progress and tradition. The novel portrays the struggles faced by small-town communities as they confront the encroachment of big business and navigate the challenges of rural life.

What are readers saying?

Annie Proulx's novel "That Old Ace in the Hole" has garnered a variety of reviews, with readers expressing divided opinions. The book seems to have elicited praise from some for Proulx's captivating writing style, while others found it lacking in certain aspects.

Many reviewers emphasize Proulx's mastery in capturing the essence of the American West, using her descriptive and atmospheric writing to transport readers to the rugged landscapes and small towns of the region. The authenticity of the setting is highly regarded, as it almost becomes a character itself.

Proulx's ability to create fully developed and complex characters is another aspect that receives acclaim from readers. The depth and realism she brings to their stories captivate readers, fostering an investment in their lives and struggles. The protagonist, Bob Dollar, particularly resonates with many readers, as they appreciate his journey and personal growth.

However, some reviewers express disappointment with the overall plot and pacing of the book. They feel that the story lacks direction at times, leading to meandering, which makes it difficult to maintain engagement. Certain readers also notice the absence of a central conflict or strong narrative drive, leaving them wanting more.

Additionally, a few reviewers note that while they find Proulx's writing style undoubtedly impressive, it can also be dense and challenging to follow. The intricate details and extensive descriptions present in the book, while adding depth, can be overwhelming and divert attention from the overall storytelling.

AceInTheHole BookwormLife VintageReads