The Admirable Crichton : Book Review

"The Admirable Crichton" by J.M. Barrie is a timeless play that delves into the complexities of class distinctions and societal norms. Known as the creator of Peter Pan, Barrie's talent shines through in this thought-provoking exploration of power dynamics and the human desire for control.

The story revolves around Lord Loam and his family, who hold progressive beliefs in the equality of all classes. However, their convictions are put to the test when they become stranded on a deserted island. As their roles reverse and the household staff takes charge, the play delves into the intricacies of social hierarchy and the fragility of societal norms.

One of the play's strengths lies in its well-developed characters. Crichton, the butler, emerges as the central figure on the island, showcasing his admirable qualities as he adapts and becomes the leader. The transformation of the family members, especially Lady Mary, highlights the impact of circumstances on their perception of class and societal hierarchy.

Barrie's writing style is witty and engaging, offering moments of humor that provide levity amidst the serious themes. The dialogue is skillfully crafted, capturing the essence of each character and their evolving perspectives. The play maintains a steady pace, building tension and intrigue as the story unfolds.

"The Admirable Crichton" also successfully explores the human desire for power and its influence on relationships. As the social order is disrupted on the island, the dynamics between the characters shift, leading to unexpected conflicts and revelations. Barrie expertly exposes the contradictions and hypocrisies of the upper class, shedding light on the flaws inherent in societal structures.

What are readers saying?

Goodreads has received a range of reviews for J.M. Barrie's "The Admirable Crichton," and the general consensus is that the book is well-received. Many readers praised the engaging storyline and thought-provoking themes, but there were also some who found the writing style and outdated language to be a hindrance to their enjoyment.

One common theme that emerged from the reviews was the book's exploration of class dynamics. Readers appreciated how the story challenged traditional hierarchies and delved into the role of servants in upper-class households. The character development of Crichton, the butler, was particularly lauded as he transformed from a dedicated servant to a natural leader on a deserted island.

The book also garnered praise for its humor. Readers found the witty dialogue and satirical elements to be entertaining and engaging. Some even drew comparisons to the humor of Oscar Wilde, highlighting the clever wordplay and comedic timing throughout the narrative.

However, a few reviewers pointed out that the writing style felt a bit old-fashioned, which hindered their full immersion in the story. Additionally, the language and cultural references were considered outdated by some readers, making it difficult to connect with the characters and their motivations.

Overall, "The Admirable Crichton" is highly regarded for its thought-provoking themes and entertaining storyline. The book's exploration of class dynamics and its humor were standout aspects for many readers. Nevertheless, the writing style and outdated language presented obstacles for some, diminishing their enjoyment of the book. Ultimately, the decision to read this book may depend on personal preferences for writing style and interest in the themes it explores.

TheAdmirableCrichton GoodreadsBook ClassicLiterature