The Brothers Grimm and Folktale : Book Review

"The Brothers Grimm and Folktale" by James M. McGlathery offers a thorough examination of the renowned brothers, Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm, and their significant contributions to the world of folklore. McGlathery delves into their lives and their work, providing a comprehensive analysis of their collection of folktales and the enduring impact they have had on literature and culture.

The book begins by introducing readers to Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm, highlighting their deep passion for gathering and preserving German folktales. McGlathery explores the motivations behind their work and the socio-political context in which they carried out their research. He demonstrates how the Grimms viewed these tales as a vital means of preserving and celebrating their country's cultural heritage.

One of the standout features of this book is the author's exploration of the fairy tales themselves. McGlathery analyzes the various themes, motifs, and archetypes present in the Grimms' tales, showcasing their significance in the development of folklore studies. He also delves into the controversy surrounding the adaptation and translation of the original tales, offering insights into the meticulous process involved in crafting the versions known today.

Furthermore, McGlathery examines the lasting impact of the Grimms' work on literature, film, and popular culture. He explores how their tales have been reimagined and adapted over time, becoming deeply ingrained in the collective consciousness of people all around the world. The book also highlights the brothers' contributions to linguistics, folklore research, and the formation of national identity.

In conclusion, "The Brothers Grimm and Folktale" is a meticulously researched and beautifully written book that provides a comprehensive exploration of the lives and work of Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm. James M. McGlathery's expertise in the field shines through as he unravels the rich history, themes, and impact of their collection of folktales. It is a captivating read for anyone interested in the Grimm brothers, folklore, or the enduring power of storytelling.

What are readers saying?

The book "The Brothers Grimm and Folktale" by James M. McGlathery has garnered a range of reviews from readers. Some individuals commended the book for its extensive examination of the Brothers Grimm and their influence on folklore. They appreciated McGlathery's diligent research and engaging writing style. These readers found the book to be a valuable resource for anyone interested in the origins and history of well-known fairy tales. They particularly enjoyed the inclusion of lesser-known tales and the exploration of how the Grimm brothers edited and interpreted these stories.

However, a number of reviewers expressed disappointment with the book. They found McGlathery's writing to be dry and lacking the captivating storytelling typically associated with fairy tales. Some felt that the book was overly academic and scholarly, rendering it less accessible for casual readers. Additionally, a few readers believed that the book focused too heavily on the lives of the Grimm brothers instead of delving deeper into the analysis and interpretation of the tales.

Another concern raised by reviewers was the organization of the book. Some found the structure to be disjointed and confusing, which made it difficult to follow the author's train of thought. They believed that a clearer and more logical progression would have greatly enhanced the reading experience.

Despite these criticisms, many readers still found value in "The Brothers Grimm and Folktale," appreciating the insight it provided into the world of fairy tales. While it may not be the most engaging read for all individuals, those with a strong interest in folklore and literary history may still find it worthwhile to explore and delve into the comprehensive content and research offered by James M. McGlathery.