The Coat-Hanger Christmas Tree : Book Review

"The Coat Hanger Christmas Tree" by Eleanor Estes is a heartwarming tale that beautifully captures the true spirit of Christmas. It takes place during the Great Depression and focuses on the Bell family, who are facing financial struggles. As the holiday season approaches, Nancy and Jim, the children of the Bell family, decide to create a Christmas tree out of coat hangers to bring some cheer into their home. Through their simple act of creativity and resourcefulness, the family finds joy and hope amidst their hardships.

Estes skillfully portrays the Bell family's resilience and determination to overcome adversity. The characters, especially Nancy and Jim, are relatable and well-developed, showcasing their ability to find happiness in even the most trying times. Their unwavering determination to make the best out of their circumstances serves as an inspiring reminder of the true essence of the holiday season.

The story also emphasizes the importance of kindness and community. As the Bell family's coat hanger Christmas tree becomes a symbol of hope, their neighbors and friends come together to offer support and assistance. This heartwarming aspect highlights the true spirit of Christmas - the act of coming together and helping one another, especially during difficult moments.

Estes' writing style is engaging, capturing the atmosphere and ambiance of the Great Depression era. The descriptive language paints a vivid picture, allowing readers to immerse themselves in the setting and empathize with the characters. Despite the challenging times portrayed, the overall tone of the book remains hopeful, accentuating the power of love, unity, and the inherent beauty of the Christmas season.

"The Coat Hanger Christmas Tree" is a delightful read for both children and adults. It imparts valuable lessons on resilience, creativity, and the significance of community, making it a perfect choice for the holiday season. Estes' storytelling prowess and endearing characters will warm the hearts of readers, leaving them with a renewed appreciation for the true meaning of Christmas.

What are readers saying?

Opinions on Eleanor Estes' book "The Coat Hanger Christmas Tree" have been mixed among readers. Some reviewers praised Estes' writing style and her ability to capture the essence of the holiday season. They found the book heartwarming and appreciated its depiction of the spirit of giving and kindness. Readers commended the relatable and well-developed characters, and they were moved by the poignant moments throughout the story. The attention to detail and vivid descriptions also added to the immersive reading experience.

However, there were also readers who felt that the book did not meet their expectations. They found the plot predictable and the narrative slow-paced. Some reviewers struggled to connect with the characters and desired more depth and complexity in their development. Despite these criticisms, many readers still found the book enjoyable and highlighted its redeeming qualities.

A recurring theme in the reviews was the nostalgic and timeless feel that "The Coat Hanger Christmas Tree" evoked. Readers were reminded of their own childhoods and the magical atmosphere of Christmas. Estes' ability to capture the simplicity and innocence of a bygone era resonated with many. This nostalgia contributed to the book's comforting and charming nature.

In conclusion, opinions on "The Coat Hanger Christmas Tree" varied among readers. While some praised Eleanor Estes' portrayal of the holiday spirit and her creation of relatable characters, others felt that the book lacked depth and had a slow pace. Nonetheless, many readers appreciated the nostalgic and timeless feel of the story, making it a worthwhile choice for those seeking a heartwarming and evocative tale during the holiday season.