The Conquest of Ireland: An Historical and Genealogical Account of the Plantation in Ulster : Book Review

George Hill's book, "The Conquest of Ireland," provides a comprehensive and in-depth historical account of the English conquest of Ireland. From the initial Anglo-Norman invasions in the 12th century to the Tudor conquest in the 16th century, Hill explores the various phases of this conquest, offering insights into key events, personalities, and political strategies that influenced Ireland's history during this period.

One of the notable strengths of Hill's work is his meticulous research and attention to detail. He brings to life the struggles and conflicts that defined the English conquest, not only through the exploration of military campaigns and battles but also by examining the complexities of political alliances, religious divisions, and cultural clashes. This multi-perspective approach allows readers to develop a comprehensive understanding of the historical events of the time.

Hill also excels in providing a broader context for the English conquest, considering the motivations of the English monarchy, the shifting dynamics of power in Europe, and the influence of the Catholic Church. By doing so, he presents a nuanced picture of the conquest, dispelling simplistic notions and offering a deeper understanding of the complex forces at play.

The writing style in "The Conquest of Ireland" is engaging and accessible, appealing to both academic and general audiences. While the book provides a detailed historical account, Hill's storytelling abilities ensure that readers remain captivated throughout. In addition, the inclusion of relevant maps, illustrations, and primary source excerpts enhances the reading experience and aids in comprehension.

Overall, "The Conquest of Ireland" is a well-researched and well-presented book that sheds light on a crucial period in Irish history. George Hill's expertise in the subject matter is evident, and his ability to synthesize complex information makes this a valuable resource for scholars, history enthusiasts, and anyone seeking a deeper understanding of the English conquest of Ireland.

What are readers saying?

The reception of George Hill's "The Conquest of Ireland" among readers is diverse, with both positive and negative reviews. Some readers appreciate the book's extensive research and historical accuracy, while others criticize its biased viewpoint and dry writing style.

One reviewer praises Hill for his meticulous attention to detail and thorough examination of Ireland's conquest. They commend the author for highlighting the various historical events and individuals involved, providing a comprehensive account. Another reader considers the book a valuable resource for understanding the complexity of the conquest, citing the inclusion of primary sources and historical documents.

However, some readers express dissatisfaction with Hill's biased portrayal of the Irish people. They argue that his perspective is heavily influenced by the British colonial narrative, resulting in a one-sided depiction of the conquest. One reviewer suggests that the book may cater more to those seeking a British-centric interpretation of history rather than a balanced account.

In terms of the writing style, several readers find the book to be dry and lacking in narrative flow. They believe that Hill's focus on factual information overshadows engaging storytelling, making for a less captivating reading experience. Additionally, some readers feel that the book becomes repetitive at times, reiterating similar information or events throughout the text.

Despite these critiques, many readers still value "The Conquest of Ireland" for its historical worth and as a starting point for further research. Some recommend supplementing it with other perspectives to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the conquest. Others suggest that the book serves as a useful introduction to Irish history for readers who are less familiar with the subject.

ConquestOfIreland IrishHistory HistoricalNonfiction