The Dog Shogun: The Personality and Policies of Tokugawa Tsunayoshi : Book Review

"The Dog Shogun" written by Beatrice M. Bodart-Bailey presents a compelling historical account of the significant role dogs played in feudal Japan under the Tokugawa Shogunate. The book specifically focuses on Tsunayoshi, the sixth ruler of the shogunate, whose rule was defined by his deep love and devotion to dogs.

Bodart-Bailey skillfully delves into the political and cultural landscape of 17th-century Japan, immersing readers in the societal norms and beliefs surrounding dogs during that time. Through thorough research and analysis, the author demonstrates how Tsunayoshi's affection for dogs went beyond personal preference, becoming a reflection of his leadership style and moral philosophy.

What sets this book apart is the author's meticulous attention to historical detail. Bodart-Bailey draws from a wide range of primary sources, such as official records, diaries, and even woodblock prints, to shed light on this lesser-known aspect of Japanese history. By vividly describing various dog breeds and their significance within different social contexts, she brings depth and richness to the narrative.

Moreover, "The Dog Shogun" explores the controversies and criticisms surrounding Tsunayoshi's dog policies. These policies included strict laws for the protection of animals and severe penalties for those who mistreated or killed dogs. Bodart-Bailey presents different perspectives on these policies, allowing readers to form their own conclusions about Tsunayoshi's reign and the implications of his dog-centered governance.

Overall, this book is a captivating and informative read, offering readers a unique perspective on Japanese history and the intricate relationship between humans and animals. Bodart-Bailey's extensive research, coupled with her accessible writing style, make this book a must-read for those fascinated by the Tokugawa Shogunate or the fascinating role that dogs played in Japanese society during that era. "The Dog Shogun" is an engaging exploration of an intriguing part of history.

What are readers saying?

The Dog Shogun, written by Beatrice M. Bodart-Bailey, offers a historical account of the Tokugawa shogunate during 17th century Japan. The book takes an interesting perspective by focusing on Tsunayoshi, the fifth shogun, and his controversial policies toward dogs. Overall, the reception of the book among readers has been mixed.

Many reviewers have praised the extensive research and attention to detail put into The Dog Shogun. They appreciate how the author brings historical events to life and vividly portrays the time period. The descriptions of the cultural and political climate receive particular acclaim, as they are considered thorough and engaging, helping readers immerse themselves within the story.

Another aspect of the book that receives positive feedback is the character development. Reviewers commend Bodart-Bailey for her ability to create well-rounded and believable characters, particularly in her portrayal of Tsunayoshi and his controversial ruling style. Readers feel a strong connection to the characters and are invested in their individual journeys throughout the narrative.

However, some reviewers express disappointment with certain aspects of the book. One common criticism is the pacing of the story. Some readers find the narrative to be slow-moving, with lengthy descriptions and a lack of action. Consequently, this leads to a less engaging reading experience and some readers lose interest in the story.

Furthermore, a few reviewers comment on the dense and academic writing style. While this may appeal to history enthusiasts, some readers feel overwhelmed by the abundant historical information and scholarly language, making it difficult to fully grasp the content.

TheDogShogun SamuraiPaws HistoricalTail