The Edmund Fitzgerald: The Song of the Bell : Book Review

"The Edmund Fitzgerald: The Song of the Bell" is a truly remarkable book that pays tribute to the tragic shipwreck that occurred in Lake Superior in 1975. Kathy-jo Wargin has done extensive research and her writing beautifully encompasses the historical facts, personal accounts, and her own poetic storytelling.

Through Wargin's skillful writing, the reader is fully immersed in the world of the Edmund Fitzgerald. From its construction to its final journey, every detail is meticulously captured, allowing us to grasp the immense power of Lake Superior and the treacherous conditions faced by the crew. The author's ability to vividly depict the Great Lakes region's atmosphere is truly commendable.

What sets this book apart is Wargin's ability to humanize the crew members of the Edmund Fitzgerald. The brief biographies she provides for each individual give us a glimpse into their lives and the impact their loss had on their loved ones. This personal touch adds an emotional depth to the story, making the tragedy all the more heartbreaking.

In addition to personal stories, the book also explores the investigations and theories surrounding the sinking of the ship. Wargin presents the various hypotheses with objectivity and clarity, allowing readers to form their own opinions. This thoughtful approach demonstrates the author's commitment to presenting a comprehensive account of the event.

"The Edmund Fitzgerald: The Song of the Bell" is not only a captivating read but also a poignant exploration of one of the most famous shipwrecks in American history. Wargin's dedication to accuracy, sensitivity, and poetic flair is evident throughout the book. Whether you are a history enthusiast or simply looking for a moving tribute to the lives lost, this book is a must-read.

What are readers saying?

Kathy-jo Wargin's book, "The Edmund Fitzgerald," has received a variety of reviews. While some readers praised the captivating storytelling and historical accuracy of the book, others felt it lacked depth and character development.

One reviewer praised Wargin's ability to bring the tragic events surrounding the sinking of the Edmund Fitzgerald to life. They appreciated the author's attention to detail and extensive research, which made the story feel authentic and engaging. Additionally, the reviewer noted that Wargin's writing style made it easy for readers to connect with the characters and empathize with their struggles.

However, another reviewer had a different perspective. They felt that the book lacked depth and failed to fully explore the complexities of the historical event. The characters, they said, were somewhat one-dimensional, and they wished for more profound insights into their lives and motivations. According to this reviewer, the book seemed to focus more on recounting the facts rather than delving into the emotional aspects of the story.

Some readers appreciated the educational aspect of "The Edmund Fitzgerald". They praised Wargin for shedding light on an important piece of history and making it accessible to a wider audience. They found the book informative and enjoyed learning about the details surrounding the sinking of the ship.

However, a few readers felt that the book didn't quite live up to their expectations. They found it overly simplified and lacking in nuance, making it more suitable for younger readers. They wished for a more in-depth exploration of the historical events and felt that the author missed an opportunity to delve into the human side of the tragedy.

TheEdmundFitzgerald GreatReads ShipwreckTales