The Envy Of The World: Fifty Years of the BBC Third Programme and Radio 3 : Book Review

"The Envy of the World" by Humphrey Carpenter is an in-depth biography delving into the life of the renowned English author, J.R.R. Tolkien. Carpenter provides a comprehensive exploration of Tolkien's early childhood, his academic pursuits, and his evolution as a masterful writer of epic tales. The biography skillfully uncovers the influences that shaped Tolkien's imagination, his creative process, and the lasting impact of his literary works, such as "The Hobbit" and "The Lord of the Rings."

Carpenter begins by immersing readers in Tolkien's formative years, delving into his deep friendships and love for storytelling, which laid the foundations for his later literary creations. The author then takes us through Tolkien's time at Oxford University, where he not only discovered his passion for philology but also crafted the intricate languages and mythologies that would eventually define the captivating world of Middle-earth. Moreover, Carpenter explores the profound impact of World War I on Tolkien and how it shaped his writing.

One of the most fascinating aspects of the biography is the insight into Tolkien's relationships with other esteemed authors and scholars, like C.S. Lewis and W.H. Auden. Carpenter illustrates how these friendships influenced Tolkien's creative process and fostered an encouraging environment for his imaginative endeavors.

Throughout the biography, Carpenter emphasizes Tolkien's meticulous attention to detail and the profound layers of meaning within his fiction. He discusses how Tolkien drew inspiration from Norse and Celtic mythology, as well as his personal Catholic faith, resulting in a rich tapestry of themes that explore the timeless battle between good and evil, the exploration of mortality, and the power of friendship.

In conclusion, "The Envy of the World" is a captivatingly researched biography that offers a comprehensive exploration of J.R.R. Tolkien's life and literary works. Carpenter's engaging writing style and deep understanding of Tolkien's motivations and influences make this book a must-read for fans of Middle-earth and anyone interested in unraveling the mind behind one of the most beloved fantasy series of all time.

What are readers saying?

"The Envy of the World" by Humphrey Carpenter has received varied reviews from readers. It has been commended by some for its thorough research and engaging writing style, while others believe it lacks depth and originality.

One aspect that many readers enjoyed was Carpenter's meticulous research and his ability to provide an encompassing history of the English language. They appreciated his attention to detail and how he presented complex linguistic concepts in a clear and accessible manner. Carpenter's writing style was also praised for being engaging and captivating, ensuring that readers remained interested throughout the book. Many readers found it to be a valuable resource for those interested in the history and evolution of the English language.

However, there were also reviewers who felt that "The Envy of the World" lacked originality and in-depth analysis. They found Carpenter's approach to be somewhat simplistic and believed that he failed to delve into the complexities of the subject matter. Some readers were disappointed with the lack of groundbreaking insights or new perspectives, feeling that the book merely reiterated familiar information about the English language. In addition, a few readers mentioned that they found certain parts of the book to be repetitive, covering similar ground without adding much new content.

Overall, "The Envy of the World" elicits mixed opinions from readers. While some appreciate Carpenter's meticulous research and engaging writing style, others find the book lacking in originality and depth. For those seeking a comprehensive history of the English language, this book may provide valuable insights. However, if you are searching for fresh perspectives or groundbreaking ideas, it may not meet your expectations.