The Extra Man : Book Review

"The Extra Man" by Jonathan Ames is a lighthearted yet eccentric novel that revolves around the life of Louis Ives, a young man who enjoys donning women's clothing. After losing his job, Louis makes the bold decision to relocate to the bustling city of New York, where he becomes roommates with Henry Harrison, an outrageously flamboyant older man who works as an "extra man" for wealthy widows. Together, they embark on a series of unconventional adventures while traversing the intricacies of their unusual lifestyles.

Ames's writing style is filled with wit and keen observations, effortlessly capturing the idiosyncrasies of his characters and the world they inhabit. Louis, in particular, stands out as a sympathetic and relatable protagonist who grapples with his own identity while yearning for acceptance. On the other hand, the larger-than-life Henry Harrison captivates the reader with his magnetic personality. Their interactions are a delightful blend of humor and occasional poignancy, exploring themes of friendship, sexuality, and self-discovery.

One of the novel's strengths is Ames's exploration of the complexity of relationships and the myriad ways in which people seek companionship. Through the experiences of Louis and Harrison, the author skillfully examines unconventional relationships and challenges societal norms. What truly stands out is Ames's ability to navigate difficult subjects with a deft touch of humor and sensitivity, resulting in a commendable and enjoyable reading experience.

Though the plot may occasionally meander, the true magic of "The Extra Man" lies in its vivid cast of characters and the author's ability to construct a unique and memorable world. Ames's writing is simultaneously insightful and entertaining, making this book a delightful read for fans of unconventional fiction. Overall, "The Extra Man" is a thought-provoking and amusing novel that will leave readers with a renewed appreciation for the quirks and complexities of life.

Jonathan Ames' novel, "The Extra Man," has elicited mixed reviews from readers. The book revolves around Louis Ives, a peculiar young man who relocates to New York City and becomes involved with the eccentric Professor Henry Harrison.

Some readers have commended Ames' unique writing style, describing it as charmingly idiosyncratic, entertaining, and captivating. They find the characters to be well-rounded and appreciate the humorous elements woven throughout the narrative. These readers believe that "The Extra Man" provides a fresh perspective on the quirks of life in New York City, offering an enjoyable and engaging reading experience.

However, there are readers who express less enthusiasm for the book. They feel that the story lacks coherence and a clear sense of direction. Some find the humor forced and not to their taste. Additionally, these readers struggle to connect with the characters, finding them unlikeable and thereby hindering their ability to fully invest in the story.

Many readers appreciate Ames' exploration of themes such as identity, loneliness, and the pursuit of meaning. They find these deeper aspects of the story thought-provoking and admire the author's sensitive and profound approach to them.

On the other hand, some readers find the book excessively explicit and occasionally vulgar. These readers may feel uncomfortable with certain scenes or descriptions, which detracts from their overall enjoyment of the story.

TheExtraMan LiteraryComedy QuirkyCharacters