The Humor of the Old South : Book Review

"The Humor of the Old South" by M. Thomas Inge is a captivating exploration of the comedic tradition in the Southern United States. Inge dives deep into the rich history of Southern humor, unveiling its development and profound influence on American literature and culture. Through a comprehensive analysis of various authors and their works, Inge sheds light on the distinctive characteristics and themes that define Southern humor, as well as its significance in reflecting the social and political climate of the region.

The book begins by providing a historical context, tracing the roots of Southern humor back to the colonial period and its connections to English, Scottish, and Irish traditions. Inge skillfully emphasizes the impact of African American culture on Southern humor, highlighting the significant contributions of enslaved individuals in shaping this comedic tradition.

Throughout the chapters, Inge introduces a diverse range of Southern writers, including well-known names such as Mark Twain, Eudora Welty, and Flannery O'Connor, and carefully analyzes their contributions to the genre. By closely examining individual works, Inge allows readers to appreciate the nuances and complexities of comedic techniques employed by these authors, spanning from satire and irony to dialect and tall tales.

Inge also delves into the intricate relationship between Southern humor and the historical and cultural context in which it emerged. He explores how humor became a form of coping with the challenges of the South, such as slavery and Reconstruction, and how it served as a means of social critique and resistance.

Overall, "The Humor of the Old South" offers a thorough and engaging examination of Southern humor, shedding light on its origins, evolution, and enduring impact on American literary and cultural traditions. Inge's meticulous research and in-depth analysis make this book a must-read for anyone seeking to understand the complexities of Southern humor and its lasting legacy.

What are readers saying?

"The Humor of the Old South" by M. Thomas Inge has received a range of reviews, with readers expressing both praise and criticism for the book. Many readers appreciate the insightful and entertaining exploration of Southern humor, as well as the author's extensive research and knowledge of the subject matter. Inge presents a comprehensive analysis of the humor prevalent in the Old South, including its origins and underlying themes, and supports his points with anecdotes and literary examples that add depth to the book.

However, some reviewers have expressed disappointment with the organization and structure of the book, finding the chapters to be disjointed and lacking a cohesive narrative. Suggestions have been made that a more focused approach, such as dividing the content by regions or themes, would have made it more accessible and easier to follow.

Another point of contention among readers is the level of academic language used in the book. While some appreciate the scholarly approach, others find it overly verbose and inaccessible, feeling it overshadows the humor Inge aims to explore.

Additionally, a few reviewers note that the book feels outdated, primarily due to its limited representation of marginalized groups and its failure to address the complexities and darker aspects of Southern humor. Critics argue that a more nuanced approach could have provided a more balanced perspective on the subject.

Despite the criticism, the majority of readers acknowledge the value of the book in shedding light on an important aspect of Southern culture. Inge's extensive research and knowledge of the topic are evident, and his analysis of the Old South's humor provides readers with valuable insights into the region's history and literature.

OldSouthHumor SouthernLaughs HumorClassics