The Impossible Revolution Phase 2: Black Power and the American Dream : Book Review

"The Impossible Revolution: Phase 2" by Lewis M. Killian is a thought-provoking exploration of the second phase of the Iranian Revolution, which unfolded between the late 1970s and early 1980s. Killian meticulously dissects the social, political, and economic factors that played a pivotal role in shaping this revolutionary period.

This book offers a comprehensive analysis of the power dynamics and resistance that characterized the Iranian Revolution during Phase 2. Killian expertly highlights the contributions and motivations of various social actors, including the urban middle class, conservative clergy, and students. By delving into their strategies, clashes, and underlying motivations, the author provides readers with a deep understanding of the intricacies surrounding this revolution.

The strength of Killian's work lies in his extensive research and reliance on primary sources. Drawing from a diverse range of interviews, newspapers, and government documents, he presents a wealth of information that enriches the narrative. This attention to detail ensures the accuracy of the account and allows readers to gain valuable insights into the specific events and developments that took place during Phase 2.

Moreover, "The Impossible Revolution: Phase 2" goes beyond a mere historical account; it also offers valuable theoretical insights. Killian introduces the concept of the "impossible revolution," which encapsulates the challenges and complexities inherent in revolutionary movements. By employing this theoretical framework, the author enables readers to grasp the broader implications of the Iranian Revolution and its significance within the broader study of social movements and revolutions.

While the book focuses on a specific period of the Iranian Revolution, it also sheds light on timeless themes and dynamics that remain relevant in contemporary society. By comprehending the motivations and strategies of social actors within the Iranian context, readers can enhance their understanding of the complexities underlying revolutionary movements in different historical and cultural contexts.

What are readers saying?

Lewis M. Killian's book, titled "The Impossible Revolution: Phase 2," has elicited varied responses from readers. Opinions on the book are divided, with some finding it insightful and thought-provoking, while others feel that it lacks depth and fails to offer a comprehensive analysis of the subject matter.

One reviewer highlights the book's examination of the intricate dynamics of revolution and social change. The reviewer appreciates the author's well-reasoned arguments and the inclusion of real-life examples, which shed light on the challenges faced by revolutionaries. They commend the book for providing a nuanced understanding of the topic.

On the other hand, another reviewer expresses disappointment with the book's lack of depth. They believe that the author falls short in providing a comprehensive analysis and instead focuses on surface-level observations. The review also criticizes the repetitive nature of the book, stating that it reiterates the same points without offering new insights.

Several readers find the book to be a valuable resource for understanding the concept of revolution. They appreciate the author's approachable writing style and clear explanations of complex ideas. According to these readers, the book serves as a solid foundation for further exploration of the subject matter.

However, a few reviewers are dissatisfied with the book's organization and structure. They struggle to follow the author's line of thought and feel that a more coherent and linear approach would have been beneficial. These readers also note the absence of a clear thesis or central argument in the book.

TheImpossibleRevolutionPhase2 RevolutionaryReads BookwormsUnite