The Last Sherlock Holmes Story : Book Review

"The Last Sherlock Holmes Story" by Michael Dibdin is a captivating and thrilling novel that presents a unique and alternate version of the famous detective's final case. The story takes place in 1888 London, where Sherlock Holmes finds himself confronted with a series of brutal murders reminiscent of the notorious Jack the Ripper killings. Dibdin expertly blends elements of suspense, mystery, and historical fiction, creating a dark and atmospheric backdrop for the story.

What sets this book apart is Dibdin's ability to skillfully capture the essence of the original Sherlock Holmes tales while infusing his own twists and surprises. The Last Sherlock Holmes Story delves into the darker aspects of Holmes' character, providing readers with a bold and controversial portrayal of the renowned detective.

One of the standout qualities of this novel is the author's masterful use of suspense. As the story unfolds, the tension steadily builds, keeping readers on the edge of their seats and eager to uncover the truth behind the grizzly murders. The unexpected twists and turns in the plot make the book thoroughly engrossing and compelling.

Moreover, Dibdin's portrayal of the characters is exceptional. Holmes is presented in a new light, delving deep into his psyche and exploring the complexities of his troubled mind. The supporting characters, such as Dr. Watson and Inspector Lestrade, are equally well-developed and add depth to the narrative.

Overall, The Last Sherlock Holmes Story is an enthralling and thought-provoking novel that will appeal to both fans of Sherlock Holmes and historical fiction. Dibdin's seamless blend of mystery, suspense, and historical accuracy creates an immersive and satisfying reading experience. Whether you're an avid Holmes enthusiast or simply enjoy a well-crafted thriller, this book is sure to leave you thoroughly satisfied.

What are readers saying?

"The Last Sherlock Holmes Story" by Michael Dibdin has garnered a variety of responses from readers on Goodreads. This novel, which presents an alternate conclusion to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's beloved detective series, has sparked diverse opinions among fans of the original Sherlock Holmes stories.

Many reviewers have commended Dibdin's writing style, finding it engaging and reminiscent of Doyle's work. They appreciate the author's attention to detail and his ability to capture the essence of the original characters, particularly Sherlock Holmes himself. These readers find the storytelling compelling and feel that Dibdin successfully delivers an enthralling mystery.

However, there are several reviewers who express disappointment with the direction in which Dibdin takes the story. They believe that the plot becomes unnecessarily intricate and convoluted, detracting from the overall enjoyment of the novel. Some readers note inconsistencies in the portrayal of Holmes and Watson, which weakens their connection to these well-established characters.

A recurring critique in the reviews is the lack of authenticity in Dibdin's attempt to emulate Doyle's writing style. Many readers find the dialogue and language forced and unnatural, failing to capture the distinct voice of Sherlock Holmes. This aspect of the book leaves some frustrated and disconnected from the story.

Furthermore, a few reviewers express dissatisfaction with the ending of "The Last Sherlock Holmes Story." They feel that the resolution is hastily concluded and lacks the cleverness and ingenuity commonly associated with Sherlock Holmes. This leaves them feeling disappointed and longing for a more gratifying conclusion.

SherlockHolmesMystery ClassicDetectiveStory MysteryNovel