The Mammoth Book of Egyptian Whodunnits : Book Review

"The Mammoth Book of Egyptian Whodunnits," edited by Mike Ashley, is an enthralling collection of short stories that immerse readers in the mysteries of ancient Egypt. Featuring contributions from various authors, this anthology presents a captivating blend of crime, suspense, and historical fiction all set within the intriguing world of pharaohs and pyramids.

Each story within this anthology offers a fresh and unique perspective on the whodunnit genre, incorporating elements of Egyptian mythology, archaeology, and ancient rituals. From perplexing murders in bustling Cairo to enigmatic crimes within hidden tombs, these tales transport readers back to a bygone era where danger lurks around every corner.

A notable highlight of this book is the diverse range of authors involved. With contributions from renowned mystery writers and experts in Egyptology, each story is infused with rich detail and authenticity. This combination of storytelling prowess and historical expertise enhances the realism of each narrative, plunging readers deep into the splendors of ancient Egypt.

The pacing and plot development of every story in this anthology are masterfully executed, ensuring that readers remain engaged and eager to unravel the mysteries at hand. The authors skillfully weave intricate clues and unexpected twists throughout their narratives, keeping the suspense palpable and leaving readers guessing until the final pages.

In conclusion, "The Mammoth Book of Egyptian Whodunnits" is an essential read for enthusiasts of both historical fiction and crime novels. With its well-crafted stories, captivating settings, and compelling characters, this anthology offers an immersive journey into the enigmatic world of ancient Egypt and the art of solving crimes.

What are readers saying?

The Mammoth Book of Egyptian Whodunnits, written by Mike Ashley, has garnered a diverse range of reviews from readers. Some readers praised the book for its intriguing premise and the unique fusion of ancient Egyptian culture with the mystery genre. They appreciated the captivating backdrop provided by the exploration of the ancient civilization and its customs. The stories were also applauded for their well-researched historical details, which added depth and authenticity to the narratives.

However, there were also readers who found the book to be underwhelming, citing inconsistencies in the quality of the stories as a primary concern. While some tales were commended for their engaging plots and well-developed characters, others were criticized for being predictable or lacking depth. Some readers believed that the overall execution of the concept could have been improved, as they felt that certain stories fell short when compared to others.

Furthermore, some readers expressed confusion and disappointment regarding the book's title, as not all of the stories strictly fit the "whodunnit" genre. With the inclusion of other subgenres, such as elements of the supernatural or thriller, the focus of the collection seemed to blur. This deviation from the expected genre caused frustration for some readers.

Another common complaint among readers was the repetitive nature of the stories, with some feeling that they followed similar patterns or formulaic structures. This predictability diminished the overall enjoyment for these readers.

In summary, The Mammoth Book of Egyptian Whodunnits by Mike Ashley has elicited a range of opinions from readers. While some appreciated the concept and historical details, others were disappointed by inconsistencies in story quality and the inclusion of different subgenres. The repetitive nature of some tales was also a point of criticism. Ultimately, readers' preferences and expectations played a significant role in shaping their opinions of the book.

EgyptianWhodunnits MammothBook MysteryInEgypt