The Mammoth Book of Perfect Crimes & Impossible Mysteries : Book Review

"The Mammoth Book of Perfect Crimes & Impossible Mysteries" is an enthralling anthology edited by Mike Ashley that brings together an impressive collection of short stories from renowned mystery writers. The book revolves around the theme of perfect crimes and impossible mysteries, offering readers a captivating journey through a wide range of intriguing tales.

The anthology opens with Edgar Allan Poe's iconic story, "The Mystery of Marie Rogêt," presenting readers with a perplexing murder case that demands their attention. Arthur Conan Doyle's contributions then take us into the world of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson, challenging us to solve seemingly inexplicable crimes alongside these beloved characters. Agatha Christie's stories, such as "The House of Lurking Death," provide a thrilling blend of intricate plots and suspenseful twists, keeping readers on the edge of their seats.

What sets this anthology apart is the diverse storytelling styles and settings it encompasses. Each story offers a unique and carefully crafted narrative, showcasing the exceptional writing skills of the authors. Additionally, the book features lesser-known works by some of the best mystery writers of all time, giving readers the opportunity to discover hidden gems within the genre.

"The Mammoth Book of Perfect Crimes & Impossible Mysteries" is an absolute must-read for mystery fans. Mike Ashley has curated an outstanding selection of stories that will captivate readers and keep them guessing until the very end. Whether you are a seasoned enthusiast of classic mystery literature or a newcomer to the genre, this anthology provides a delightful journey into the realm of perfect crimes and seemingly unsolvable mysteries.

The Mammoth Book of Perfect Crimes & Impossible Mysteries edited by Mike Ashley has garnered a range of reactions from readers. Some reviewers have heaped praise on the collection, lauding its diverse selection of stories and the captivating intrigue they offer. They commend the anthology for featuring a wide range of authors, including famous mystery writers like Arthur Conan Doyle and Agatha Christie. Readers found themselves thoroughly engrossed in the tales and relished the challenge of deciphering the baffling mysteries presented within. The clever plots and unexpected twists and turns held their attention until the very last page.

However, not all reviewers were as impressed, as they found the stories to be somewhat predictable and lacking in originality. Some noted that certain plots and solutions felt recycled from other mystery fiction, leading to disappointment and a sense of repetition. These readers had been hoping for more unique and challenging crime puzzles, and were let down by the familiarity of some of the narratives.

In addition, some readers commented on the inconsistency of the overall quality of the stories. While some stood out as shining examples of the genre, others fell flat and failed to captivate the audience. This disparity left some readers feeling dissatisfied, wishing for a more consistently high standard throughout the collection.

Furthermore, a few readers found certain stories to have an outdated or difficult-to-follow writing style. They felt that these stories seemed out of place in a modern anthology, interrupting the overall reading experience.

In summary, The Mammoth Book of Perfect Crimes & Impossible Mysteries garners a mixed response from readers. While many appreciate the variety and engrossing nature of the stories, others express disappointment in the lack of originality and inconsistency in quality.

PerfectCrimesImpossibleMysteries MammothBook CrimeMystery