The Midwife's Apprentice: A Unit Plan (Litplans on CD) : Book Review

"The Midwife's Apprentice" by Janine H. Sherman is a captivating historical fiction novel set in medieval England. It tells the story of Alyce, a young girl who faces abandonment and must navigate life on her own. Eventually, she finds herself becoming the apprentice of a skilled midwife named Jane Sharp. Through her apprenticeship, Alyce learns the art of delivering babies and caring for expectant mothers, all while undergoing a profound transformation.

One of the novel's strengths is Sherman's ability to create a realistic and immersive setting. Her descriptions of medieval England transport readers back in time, offering a vivid portrayal of the sights, sounds, and smells of the era. The author's attention to detail, whether it's the bustling markets, the humble cottages, or the dimly lit birthing chamber, is commendable and adds depth to the story.

Alyce's journey from an abandoned and nameless girl to a skilled midwife's apprentice is both inspiring and heartwarming. Through her experiences, readers witness Alyce's growth and development, as she learns valuable lessons about herself and the world. Sherman effectively captures the challenges and hardships faced by Alyce, making her journey relatable and compelling.

The relationship between Alyce and Jane Sharp, her mentor, is a highlight of the novel. Jane's expertise and no-nonsense demeanor provide a stark contrast to Alyce's initial naivety. As the two women form a unique bond, their relationship becomes the backbone of the story, showcasing the power of mentorship and female friendships.

"The Midwife's Apprentice" also explores important themes such as gender roles, social hierarchy, and the value of knowledge. Through Alyce's experiences, readers are exposed to the complexities of medieval society, where women were often marginalized and limited in their career options. The book prompts readers to reflect on these issues and consider the significance of education and empowerment.

What are readers saying?

"The Midwife's Apprentice" by Janine H. Sherman is a highly acclaimed historical fiction novel that follows the journey of a young girl named Alyce in medieval England. The book has garnered mixed reviews, with readers praising Sherman's detailed and vivid storytelling. They appreciate the accurate depiction of the time period and the atmospheric descriptions that transport them to the medieval world. Many readers also find the character development of Alyce to be strong and commend the author for her ability to bring the story to life through the protagonist's growth and learning during her apprenticeship.

However, some readers feel that the pacing of the plot is slow and lacks excitement. They desire more action and additional layers to the story, as they find the book's climax and resolution to be underwhelming. Another common criticism is that the supporting characters are not well-developed, lacking depth and substance, which makes it difficult for readers to connect with them. Additionally, some readers find the dialogue to be unnatural and awkward at times, which hampers their overall enjoyment of the book.

Despite these critiques, the novel has been appreciated for its themes of independence, self-discovery, and female empowerment. Sherman is applauded for highlighting the importance of education and the pursuit of one's passions, particularly within a patriarchal society. These themes resonate with readers, making the book impactful and inspiring.

In conclusion, "The Midwife's Apprentice" receives a mix of positive and critical reviews. While some readers enjoy the detailed storytelling, strong character development, and powerful themes, others find the pacing slow and the supporting characters lacking. Nevertheless, if you have an interest in historical fiction and stories centered around personal growth, this book may still be worth exploring.