In "The Myth of the Holy Cow" by D.N. Jha, the author takes a thought-provoking approach to challenge the widely held beliefs about the sacredness of cows in Indian culture. Through a well-researched and scholarly examination of the historical, cultural, and religious aspects surrounding the veneration of cows in Hinduism, Jha presents a compelling argument that cows have not always been considered sacred in India.
Jha delves into ancient scriptures, archaeological evidence, and historical records to debunk the notion that the sacredness of cows has been a longstanding tradition in India. He reveals that the veneration of cows is a relatively recent development, originating from the Brahmanical tradition that emerged during the early medieval period. According to Jha, the Brahmanical caste used the concept of the holy cow to consolidate their social and political power.
One of the book's notable contributions is its exploration of the dietary practices of ancient India. Jha highlights the prevalence of beef consumption in both Vedic and non-Vedic communities, revealing that the prohibition on beef consumption came about much later due to social and political influences.
Available on Audible
By challenging readers to critically examine their cultural and religious beliefs regarding cows in Hinduism, "The Myth of the Holy Cow" provides a fresh perspective on this controversial topic. Through meticulous research and thorough analysis, Jha offers valuable insights into the complex relationship between cows, religion, and society in India.
While the book may spark controversy and debate, it encourages readers to reconsider long-held assumptions and to approach the subject with a more open mind. Overall, "The Myth of the Holy Cow" is a thought-provoking and enlightening read that sheds new light on the historical and cultural context surrounding the veneration of cows in India.
What are readers saying?
The book "The Myth of the Holy Cow" by D.N. Jha has received a variety of reviews, showcasing a mix of opinions. Some reviewers have positively acknowledged the author's effort in debunking the religious belief surrounding the sacred status of cows in Hinduism. They commend Jha for his extensive research and the compelling evidence he presents to support his argument. These readers find the book enlightening and thought-provoking as it sheds light on the historical, cultural, and social aspects related to cow veneration. They appreciate Jha's attempt to challenge prevailing beliefs and initiate a dialogue on this sensitive topic.
However, not all reviewers are satisfied with the book. Some criticize Jha for adopting a biased approach and overlooking certain historical and cultural evidence that contradicts his arguments. They argue that the author's intention seems to belittle Hinduism rather than providing an objective analysis. These readers firmly believe that cow veneration is deeply ingrained in Hindu tradition and should not be dismissively labeled as a myth.
While a few readers find the book informative and educational, they struggle with its academic writing style. They feel that Jha's narrative is dense and inaccessible, making it difficult to fully grasp the material. These readers suggest that the book could benefit from a more reader-friendly approach without compromising its intellectual rigor.
Despite its mixed reviews, some reviewers appreciate Jha's work but find his conclusions somewhat lacking. They believe that the book could have delved deeper into the psychological, sociological, and ecological aspects of cow veneration, providing a more comprehensive and compelling perspective. According to these readers, a broader exploration would have made the book even more relevant and thought-provoking.
Overall, "The Myth of the Holy Cow" evokes varying opinions among readers. While some appreciate the author's research and his challenging of prevailing beliefs, others criticize the book for its perceived bias and dense writing style.
#TheMythoftheHolyCow #Goodreads #BookRecommendations