The People Themselves: Popular Constitutionalism and Judicial Review : Book Review

"The People Themselves" by Larry D. Kramer offers a fascinating and thought-provoking exploration of the history of popular constitutionalism in America. Throughout the book, Kramer argues that the power to interpret the Constitution ultimately rests with the people, rather than the government or the courts. He emphasizes the right and responsibility of the people to actively participate in shaping the meaning and application of the Constitution.

Kramer provides a thorough analysis of popular constitutionalism throughout American history, delving into key events such as the Founding Era, the Civil War, the Civil Rights Movement, and contemporary debates surrounding issues like same-sex marriage and healthcare. With meticulous research and clear writing, Kramer paints a vivid picture of the ongoing struggle between the people and the institutions of government.

One of the strengths of this book is its accessibility. Kramer explains complex legal concepts and historical events in a manner that can be easily understood by readers who may not have a background in constitutional law. By combining legal analysis with compelling narratives, he creates an engaging and enjoyable reading experience.

Furthermore, Kramer's arguments are well-supported by extensive research and a wide range of primary and secondary sources. He draws upon legal documents, historical records, court cases, and scholarly works, providing readers with the necessary evidence to make informed judgments about his ideas.

In conclusion, "The People Themselves" is a must-read for those interested in American constitutional history and the ongoing debate surrounding the role of the people in shaping the interpretation and application of the Constitution. Kramer's insightful analysis and compelling arguments make this book a valuable contribution to the field of constitutional law, offering a thought-provoking exploration of democracy in action.

What are readers saying?

Larry D. Kramer's book "The People Themselves" has garnered a range of reactions from readers. Delving into the tensions and conflicts surrounding the creation of the United States Constitution, the book has been commended for its extensive research and meticulous examination of historical events. Readers found Kramer's ability to present complex ideas in a clear and concise manner to be both informative and engaging.

However, some reviewers were disappointed with the book's writing style, which they perceived as dry and academic. They felt that the lack of narrative flow made it challenging to become fully engrossed in the material. Additionally, the abundance of details and footnotes, while appreciated by some, was seen by others as distracting and occasionally tedious to follow.

The organization of the book also proved to be a point of contention among readers. The frequent shifts between different time periods and ideas left some feeling confused and disconnected, hindering their ability to grasp the overall narrative and the significance of certain events.

Despite these criticisms, many reviewers still lauded the insights and perspectives provided by "The People Themselves." They found the book thought-provoking and valued the nuanced analysis of the political and social dynamics during the constitutional debates. Furthermore, readers appreciated how the book shed light on lesser-known aspects of American history, offering a fresh perspective on familiar events.

Overall, "The People Themselves" received a mix of positive and negative feedback from readers. While the book's thorough research and informative content were widely praised, others were disappointed by its writing style and organizational structure. For those with a keen interest in American history and a willingness to delve into the intricacies of constitutional debates, this book may prove to be a worthwhile exploration.

ThePeopleThemselves BookRecommendations LiteraryCommunity