The Performance of Self in Student Writing : Book Review

"The Performance of Self in Student Writing" by Thomas Newkirk is a thought-provoking and insightful book that delves into the intricate relationship between self-expression and writing within the context of student work. Newkirk argues that students often find themselves under the pressure to conform to a certain writing style or persona, thereby hindering their ability to authentically express their true selves. Through the use of student writing examples, the author effectively explores how this performance of self significantly impacts the authenticity and quality of their work.

One of the central points Newkirk makes is that students are acutely aware of their intended audience, whether it be their teacher, peers, or future employers. This awareness often leads students to adopt a specific role or perform a version of themselves that they believe will be well-received by their audience. However, Newkirk asserts that this performance stifles creativity and prevents students from developing their own distinct voice.

Furthermore, Newkirk addresses the issue of the writing process itself, highlighting how the pressure for students to produce flawless and grammatically correct work often limits their ability to explore and experiment with language. To combat this, he suggests that teachers place more emphasis on the drafting and revision process, allowing students the freedom to take risks and make mistakes in order to find their true voices.

Throughout the book, Newkirk provides practical strategies and engaging anecdotes to aid teachers in creating a more authentic and supportive writing environment for their students. He encourages teachers to give students the freedom to establish personal connections to their writing topics and to foster a classroom culture that values individual expression over conformity.

In conclusion, "The Performance of Self in Student Writing" offers a compelling and engaging examination of the intricate dynamics involved in student writing. Newkirk's ideas and suggestions provide valuable resources for educators seeking to empower their students and cultivate a genuine sense of self in their writing.

What are readers saying?

Thomas Newkirk's book, "The Performance of Self in Student Writing," has received a range of reviews from readers. While some readers found the insights and discussions presented by the author to be valuable, others felt that the book was repetitive and lacked practical application.

Positive reviews highlighted the thought-provoking nature of the book and its ability to challenge traditional perspectives on student writing. Readers commended Newkirk for shedding light on the performative aspects of writing and empowering students to express themselves authentically. The book's emphasis on understanding students' identities and experiences in relation to their writing was also praised.

However, some readers were disappointed by the lack of concrete strategies provided for incorporating the concepts discussed into teaching practices. It was mentioned that the repetition of certain ideas became tiresome, and the book was criticized for lacking practical examples and actionable guidance. Additionally, some reviewers found the book's tone and writing style to be dense and challenging to follow at times.

The structure of the book received mixed reviews as well. While some readers appreciated the organization of chapters into specific topics for easy navigation, others found it to be fragmented and disjointed, making it difficult to grasp the overarching message.

Despite the criticisms, many readers still found value in "The Performance of Self in Student Writing" and believed it could be beneficial for educators and researchers interested in exploring the complex relationship between writing and identity. However, it is important to note that readers' experiences and opinions vary, underscoring the subjective nature of their reviews.

PerformanceOfSelf StudentWriting WritingAnalysis