The Poems of Herman Melville : Book Review

Delve into the poetic brilliance of the renowned American author, Herman Melville, with "The Poems of Herman Melville." Edited by Douglas Robillard, this comprehensive collection sheds light on Melville's lesser-known talent for poetry, providing readers with an in-depth look into his masterful command of language and thought-provoking ideas.

Robillard's commendable editing skills are on display as he organizes the poems into thematic sections, allowing readers to explore specific aspects of Melville's poetic prowess. The collection covers a wide range of topics, from nature and the environment to love, spirituality, and the human condition. Through vivid imagery and metaphors, Melville evokes strong emotions and provokes contemplation with each poem.

One of the strengths of this collection is its ability to showcase Melville's poetic brilliance alongside his more famous works like "Moby-Dick" and "Billy Budd." By exploring Melville's poetry, readers gain a deeper understanding of his multifaceted literary talent that extends beyond his acclaimed novels. The poems reveal Melville's keen observational skills, philosophical musings, and intense emotional depth.

Robillard's insightful introduction adds essential context, situating Melville's poems within the author's life and literary career. This introduction helps readers grasp the significance of Melville's poetry in relation to his larger body of work, providing valuable insights into the inspirations behind his verses. Robillard's commentary further enhances the reading experience, allowing for a more comprehensive appreciation of both the poems and Melville as a poet.

Overall, "The Poems of Herman Melville" is a must-read for fans of Melville's writings and poetry lovers alike. This collection stands out with its meticulous editing, diverse selection of poems, and insightful commentary. It offers a captivating journey through the poetic mind of one of America's greatest literary figures, showcasing Melville's talent for crafting evocative verses that continue to resonate with readers today.

What are readers saying?

"The Poems of Herman Melville" by Douglas Robillard has garnered varying reviews from readers. Some applaud the collection for its valuable insights into Melville's inner thoughts and consider it a significant addition to the literary canon. These readers find the poems thought-provoking, engaging, and a unique glimpse into Melville's artistic journey and personal emotions.

However, not all readers were captivated by the collection. Some criticized the poems, claiming that they lacked the depth and complexity expected from a renowned author like Melville. These reviewers often struggled with the dense and challenging language used in the poems, which hindered their overall enjoyment and appreciation of the work.

Another point of contention among reviewers was the commentary and analysis provided by Robillard. Some felt that his insights fell short of fully grasping the meaning and significance of the poems, leaving them wanting a more comprehensive exploration.

The organization of the poems within the collection also sparked mixed feedback. While some readers found the arrangement logical and coherent, others deemed it haphazard and confusing. The latter group believed that a clearer structure would have enhanced the reading experience and made it easier to navigate through the poems.

Ultimately, the reception of "The Poems of Herman Melville" depends on readers' familiarity with Melville's work and their personal preferences in poetry. While some appreciate the illumination it provides into Melville's lesser-known writing, others find the poems challenging to comprehend and lacking in depth. The commentary and organization of the collection also receive mixed feedback, with some finding it insightful and others feeling it falls short.

HermanMelvillePoems ClassicLiterature GoodreadsReading