The Politics of the British Army : Book Review

"The Politics of the British Army" by Hew Strachan offers a deep dive into the often overlooked political dynamics that shape the British military. Strachan, a renowned military historian, meticulously examines the complex relationship between the army and the government, shedding light on the influence of politics on military decision-making.

Throughout the book, Strachan explores significant historical moments to illustrate the intricate interplay of power between politicians and military leaders. He delves into the army's involvement in domestic politics, such as during the English Civil War and the Glorious Revolution, as well as its role in colonial conflicts and major wars like World War I and World War II. By dissecting these events, the author reveals the strong political dimensions that underpin military operations.

One of the notable strengths of Strachan's writing is his engaging and accessible style. He successfully makes complex concepts and historical contexts understandable for both scholarly readers and general enthusiasts. His extensive research and insightful analysis combine to provide a nuanced account of the army's political evolution throughout history. By reading this book, one can gain a deeper understanding of the intricate dynamics that shape military strategy, decision-making processes, and the allocation of resources.

An especially noteworthy aspect of the book is its exploration of the delicate balance between military autonomy and civilian control. Strachan emphasizes how political agendas can shape military objectives and vice versa. He deeply examines the influence of public opinion, lobbying, and inter-service rivalries on military policy, offering valuable insights into the forces that shape military planning and decision-making.

In conclusion, "The Politics of the British Army" is a comprehensive examination of the complex relationship between politics and the military. Strachan's rigorous research, combined with his engaging writing style, makes this book an essential read for anyone interested in the political dimensions of military affairs. Whether you are a history enthusiast, a scholar, or a military professional, this book offers valuable insights into the nuances of the British army's political landscape.

What are readers saying?

Hew Strachan's book, "The Politics of the British Army," has garnered a range of opinions from readers. Some found the book to be a captivating and thorough exploration of the political challenges faced by the British Army. They praised Strachan's extensive research and knowledge of military history, highlighting how he delved into the interactions between officers and politicians during various conflicts. These readers appreciated the valuable insights presented in the well-written book, shedding light on the power dynamics within the army.

However, others felt that the book was excessively dense, lacking a clear focus and organization. They found it difficult to follow at times and expressed a desire for a more concise and focused approach to the political aspects of the British Army. These readers also criticized the lack of engaging storytelling, noting that the book read more like a dry textbook rather than a captivating historical account. They felt that personal anecdotes or vivid descriptions would have brought the subject matter to life.

Despite these criticisms, many readers commended Strachan's objective approach to the subject matter. They appreciated his balanced perspective, acknowledging both the successes and failures of the British Army's political dealings. This contributed to their overall appreciation of the book's content.

In summary, "The Politics of the British Army" receives a mix of positive and negative reviews. Readers praise its comprehensive research and informative content, but criticize its density and lack of focus. Whether or not this book would be suitable for a reader depends on their level of interest and prior knowledge of military history.