The Presocratics : Book Review

"The Presocratics" by Philip Wheelwright offers a comprehensive exploration of the ancient Greek philosophers who paved the way for Western philosophy. It serves as an excellent introduction to these thinkers, providing an in-depth analysis of their ideas and contributions.

Wheelwright delves into the philosophical concepts of key figures like Thales, Anaximander, and Parmenides, thoroughly examining their theories on topics such as metaphysics, cosmology, and the nature of reality. What sets this book apart is Wheelwright's ability to present these complex ideas in a clear and accessible manner. He breaks them down into digestible pieces, making them understandable for readers with varying levels of philosophical knowledge. Additionally, Wheelwright offers insightful commentary and analysis, enhancing our understanding of these ancient thinkers and their significance in the development of Western thought.

One of the book's notable strengths is Wheelwright's attention to detail. He meticulously examines the surviving fragments and testimonies of the Presocratics, reconstructing their ideas and exploring the philosophical controversies that surround them. He also incorporates the insights of later philosophers and scholars, providing a comprehensive perspective on the Presocratics.

"The Presocratics" also offers valuable historical and cultural context. Wheelwright situates the ideas of these ancient Greek philosophers within the intellectual climate of their time, shedding light on the environment in which they flourished.

Overall, "The Presocratics" is an exceptional resource for anyone interested in understanding the foundations of Western philosophy. With its accessible writing style, detailed analysis, and comprehensive exploration of the Presocratic thinkers, this book provides valuable insights into the intellectual landscape of ancient Greece and the origins of Western thought.

What are readers saying?

Philip Ellis Wheelwright's book "The Presocratics" has received a range of reviews from readers. Some reviewers praised the book for its comprehensive exploration of the Presocratic philosophers, applauding the author's detailed examination of their ideas. They found the book's organization to be effective in highlighting the evolution of philosophical thought during this period. Many readers, particularly those studying philosophy or interested in ancient Greek thinkers, considered it a valuable resource and even a classic in the field.

However, not all readers were satisfied with "The Presocratics." Some critics found Wheelwright's writing style to be dense and academic, making it challenging to grasp the concepts and arguments presented, especially for those without a strong background in philosophy. These readers struggled to understand the content and considered the lack of coherence and flow detrimental to their reading experience.

Others expressed disappointment with the book's focus, believing that Wheelwright placed too much emphasis on the metaphysical aspects of Presocratic philosophy and neglected important topics such as ethics and politics. This limited perspective left some readers yearning for a more comprehensive analysis of the philosophers' ideas.

Another common criticism was that "The Presocratics" felt outdated. Some readers felt that it relied too heavily on the historical context in which it was written, making it less accessible and relevant to modern readers. They felt that Wheelwright's interpretations did not take into account more recent scholarship and insights on the Presocratic philosophers.

Overall, "The Presocratics" has both its admirers and detractors. While some readers found it to be a valuable and comprehensive exploration of ancient Greek philosophy, others were less impressed. The book's dense writing style, narrow focus, and outdated nature were among the main criticisms. It is recommended primarily for those with a strong background in philosophy seeking a detailed analysis of the Presocratic philosophers.

PresocraticPhilosophy AncientGreekThinkers PhilosophicalInquiry