The Prophet and the Pharaoh : Book Review

"The Prophet and the Pharaoh" by Gilles Kepel is a well-regarded exploration of the intricate relationship between Islam and the state in Egypt. Kepel, a renowned scholar and expert on Islam, conducts extensive research and conducts personal interviews with key figures to provide readers with a comprehensive analysis of the tensions and conflicts that have unfolded in Egypt over the years.

The book begins by delving into the historical context, tracing the origins of political Islam in Egypt back to the 19th century. Kepel sheds light on the influential individuals and significant events that shaped the development of the movement, taking into account the impact of colonization, secular nationalism, and various strains of Islamist ideology on Egypt's political and religious landscape.

A significant focus of the book is on the rise of the Muslim Brotherhood and its role in Egyptian society. Kepel provides a nuanced understanding of the organization's goals, methods, and relationship with the Egyptian state. He comprehensively explores the often contentious dynamics between the Muslim Brotherhood and the ruling regime, including periods of repression and oppression faced by the organization. Kepel analyzes the underlying factors that have contributed to the Brotherhood's resilience and enduring presence as a political force in Egypt.

Throughout the book, Kepel also examines the phenomenon of jihadist movements and their impact on Egyptian society. He investigates the links between these movements, the Muslim Brotherhood, and the wider Islamist landscape. Kepel critically analyzes the state's efforts in combating radicalism, highlighting both successes and failures in its approach.

In summary, "The Prophet and the Pharaoh" is a valuable resource for those interested in understanding the complex relationship between Islam and the state in Egypt. Gilles Kepel's meticulous research and insightful analysis provide readers with a deeper understanding of the historical, political, and social factors that have molded Egypt's religious landscape. This book is an essential read for anyone looking to comprehend the dynamics of Islam in the Middle East and its impact on politics and society.

What are readers saying?

Gilles Kepel's book "The Prophet and the Pharaoh" has elicited a range of responses from readers. The book delves into the historical and geopolitical connection between Islam and Egypt, focusing specifically on the presidency of Hosni Mubarak. Here is a summary of the various reviews:

1. Many readers commended Kepel's meticulous analysis and extensive research. They found the book highly informative, appreciating the author's ability to delve into complex historical and political events. Kepel's portrayal of the intricate relationship between Islam and Egypt was commended as insightful and thought-provoking.

2. However, some reviewers felt that the book lacked focus and tended to be overly academic. They found the writing style to be dense and difficult to follow, which made it challenging to fully grasp the concepts presented. These readers desired a more engaging and approachable narrative.

3. A significant number of readers applauded Kepel's neutral and unbiased approach. They admired his skill in presenting diverse perspectives without taking sides or advocating for a particular agenda. This balanced approach was praised for providing a nuanced understanding of the subject matter.

4. Some critics pointed out that the book may have become outdated since its publication in 1984, as it mainly focuses on events from the 1970s and early 1980s. They believed that a more recent edition would have been beneficial, considering the significant political changes that have transpired since then.

TheProphetandthePharaoh AncientEgyptianSaga EnlightenmentandRevelation