Thomas J. DiLorenzo's book, "The Real Lincoln," presents a thought-provoking and nuanced analysis of Abraham Lincoln's presidency. Contrary to the widely accepted view of Lincoln as a heroic figure who emancipated slaves and preserved the Union, DiLorenzo argues that he was a power-hungry politician who exploited the issue of slavery to advance his own political agenda.
The author digs into Lincoln's policies and demonstrates how they expanded the federal government's power and encroached upon individual liberties. According to DiLorenzo, Lincoln's motive for waging war against the South was not solely to end slavery, but rather to consolidate his own power and keep the Union intact at any cost. DiLorenzo also sheds light on the economic motivations behind the war, highlighting the North's desire to protect their own economic interests.
One of the book's strengths lies in DiLorenzo's extensive research. His presentation of historical evidence and primary sources offers a compelling case that challenges traditional beliefs about Lincoln's legacy. Additionally, his accessible writing style makes complex historical concepts understandable for readers who may not have a background in the subject.
Available on Audible
However, it is worth noting that "The Real Lincoln" has generated controversy and sparked debate among historians. While some commend DiLorenzo for his fresh perspective and meticulous research, others criticize him for downplaying the significance of slavery and placing too much emphasis on economic factors. Readers should approach this book with an open mind and consider alternative scholarly perspectives to form their own conclusions.
Ultimately, "The Real Lincoln" provides valuable insights into the presidency of Abraham Lincoln, regardless of whether one agrees with DiLorenzo's arguments. The book prompts readers to critically reevaluate their understanding of Lincoln's legacy, challenging the prevailing narrative surrounding this iconic figure in American history.
What are readers saying?
"The Real Lincoln" by Thomas J. DiLorenzo has sparked a range of reactions from readers. This thought-provoking book has generated much discussion and debate surrounding Abraham Lincoln's presidency and his lasting impact on American history.
Some readers highly praise DiLorenzo's alternative perspective on Lincoln, rating the book highly and appreciating the author's willingness to challenge the traditional image of Lincoln as a heroic figure. These readers find the book insightful, well-researched, and stimulating, as it leads them to reevaluate Lincoln's policies, which they believe were detrimental to the Constitution and individual liberties.
However, there are also readers who disagree with DiLorenzo's portrayal of Lincoln and criticize his arguments. They argue that the author's views are biased and excessively critical, disregarding Lincoln's accomplishments and character. These readers cite factual errors and inconsistencies within the book as factors that undermine its credibility. Some express disappointment that DiLorenzo did not provide a more balanced and nuanced analysis of Lincoln's presidency.
Furthermore, several reviewers note that "The Real Lincoln" can be challenging to follow at times due to its dense and scholarly nature. The writing style is described as dry and academic, making it less accessible to a wider audience. Some readers suggest that the book is more suitable for those with a strong interest in history or politics.
Despite these varying opinions, it is evident that "The Real Lincoln" has successfully stimulated meaningful conversations among readers. By presenting an alternative perspective on Lincoln's presidency, the book invites readers to critically reconsider the conventional narrative surrounding Lincoln's legacy. Regardless of agreement or disagreement with DiLorenzo's arguments, readers are prompted to engage in thoughtful analysis and reevaluate Abraham Lincoln's impact on American history.
TheRealLincoln AbrahamLincoln AmericanHistory