The Real Middle-Earth: Magic and Mystery in the Dark Ages : Book Review

"The Real Middle Earth: Exploring the Magic and Mystery of the Middle Ages," authored by Brian Bates, takes readers on a captivating journey through the medieval era and its profound influence on J.R.R. Tolkien's beloved fantasy realm, Middle-Earth. This book offers a fresh perspective by examining the real-life people, places, and events that inspired Tolkien's literary creations.

Bates sets the stage by providing the historical context in which Tolkien lived and worked. He explores the impact of Tolkien's experiences during World War I and his academic career, showcasing how these factors shaped his imaginative world. By delving into the vibrant medieval world that fascinated Tolkien, Bates highlights the folklore, mythology, and legends that captured his imagination.

Through a comprehensive analysis of Tolkien's writings, Bates uncovers the deeper meanings and themes in his work. He examines the significance of nature, the use of archetypes, and the incorporation of ancient languages, drawing parallels between the real medieval history and the fictional Middle-Earth. This exploration allows readers to appreciate the rich layers of storytelling and the messages within Tolkien's stories.

A notable strength of this book lies in Bates' exploration of the art of storytelling itself. He explores how storytelling served as a means of transmitting knowledge, preserving cultural heritage, and fostering a sense of community in traditional societies. With this insight, readers can better understand Tolkien's dedication to creating an immersive world that resonates with readers on a personal level.

"The Real Middle Earth" is a meticulously researched and engaging book that offers an insightful analysis of the historical and cultural influences behind Tolkien's Middle-Earth. Whether one is a fan of Tolkien's works or simply interested in exploring the medieval era, Brian Bates provides a captivating exploration that illuminates the magic and mystery of both the real and fictional realms.

What are readers saying?

"The Real Middle-earth: Exploring the Magic and Mystery of the Middle Ages" by Brian Bates has received a range of reviews from readers. The book aims to delve into the historical and cultural influences that inspired J.R.R. Tolkien's creation of Middle-earth.

Reviewers have commented on the historical accuracy and depth of research presented in the book. Bates is commended for his extensive knowledge of the Middle Ages and his ability to connect it to Tolkien's work. Many readers appreciated the thorough analysis and exploration of various aspects of medieval life, such as spirituality, poetry, and mythology.

However, some reviewers found the book to be overly academic and dense, making it challenging for those without prior knowledge of the Middle Ages or Tolkien's works. The inclusion of extensive footnotes and citations was also criticized for interrupting the flow of the narrative.

Another recurring criticism was the repetitive nature of the book. Some readers felt that certain concepts or ideas were reiterated throughout the chapters, which made the reading experience somewhat monotonous.

Additionally, a few reviewers expressed disappointment with the lack of new insights or original ideas presented in the book. They felt that Bates was largely rehashing information that had already been extensively covered by other Tolkien scholars.

TheRealMiddleEarth FantasyBook Tolkien