The Reinvention of Obscenity: Sex, Lies, and Tabloids in Early Modern France : Book Review

In "The Reinvention of Obscenity" by Joan DeJean, readers are taken on a fascinating journey through the history of obscenity in French literature, art, and society. DeJean argues that during the 17th and 18th centuries, the French redefined and transformed the concept of obscenity, using it as a form of social commentary and artistic expression. Throughout the book, she examines the works of renowned writers and artists such as Molière, Baudelaire, and Manet, who pushed the boundaries of what was considered obscene at the time, challenging societal norms and conventions.

What sets DeJean's book apart is her comprehensive analysis of the various cultural, political, and literary factors that influenced the reinvention of obscenity in France. By delving into the roles of the aristocracy, the rise of urbanization, and the impacts of censorship, she provides a well-rounded understanding of how these factors shaped French literature and art. Through a careful examination of literature, plays, paintings, and engravings, DeJean offers a nuanced and engaging portrayal of how obscenity became not only a tool for social criticism but also a means of exploring complex and taboo topics.

The strength of DeJean's work lies in her ability to connect the historical context with the artistic and cultural developments of the time. She effectively demonstrates how authors and artists of the era used obscenity to challenge the status quo and ignite debates on religion, politics, and sexuality. Thanks to her meticulous research and analysis, readers gain a deeper understanding of the multifaceted nature of obscenity and its significance in shaping French culture.

"The Reinvention of Obscenity" is a thought-provoking and insightful book that highlights the transformative power of art and literature in society. DeJean's engaging writing style, combined with her extensive exploration of French history and culture, make this book a valuable resource for anyone interested in understanding the evolution of obscenity and its impact on artistic expression. By examining the changing definitions of obscenity, DeJean offers a fresh perspective on the ways in which literature and art can challenge societal norms and contribute to social and cultural change.

"The Reinvention of Obscenity" by Joan DeJean has garnered a range of responses from readers. While some commend the book for its thought-provoking exploration of the historical concept of obscenity, others believe that the writing style and organization could have been improved.

Numerous readers appreciate DeJean's extensive research and her ability to shed light on the historical context of obscenity. They find her analysis of how society's perception of obscene material has evolved over the years to be both captivating and informative. Readers particularly enjoy the author's examination of the intricate relationship between art, literature, and politics and how this dynamic has influenced our understanding of obscenity.

However, some reviewers criticize the book for its density and difficulty in comprehension. These readers suggest that the academic writing style may not appeal to a wider audience. Furthermore, a few express disappointment with the lack of a clear structure in the book, noting that it jumps between different time periods and topics without a cohesive thread.

Opinions also vary on the readability of DeJean's prose. While some find it engaging and appreciate her use of examples and anecdotes to illustrate her points, others consider it dry and lacking liveliness. Some reviewers also mention that the book could benefit from more concise explanations and tighter editing.

Overall, "The Reinvention of Obscenity" elicits mixed reviews. Readers who enjoy historical analysis and are willing to grapple with complex ideas may find it rewarding. However, those seeking a more accessible and well-organized read might be disappointed. Despite its flaws, the book offers valuable insights into the evolving perceptions of obscenity throughout history.

ObscenityReinvented BookLove LiteraryDelight