The Silmarillion, Volume 2 (J.R.R. Tolkien) : Book Review

"The Silmarillion: Volume 2" is a posthumously published companion book by J.R.R. Tolkien that expands upon the mythology and history of his renowned fantasy world, Middle-earth. It serves as a valuable resource for fans of his masterpiece, "The Lord of the Rings," exploring the origins of the world, ancient conflicts, and the creation of various races and creatures.

Divided into five parts, "The Silmarillion: Volume 2" offers a comprehensive exploration of Tolkien's extensive lore. The first part, "Quenta Silmarillion," delves into the events of the First Age, with a particular focus on the Silmarils, precious gems that hold immense power. The second part, "Valaquenta," introduces the Valar and the Maiar, ethereal beings who shape the world and combat evil forces.

The third part, "Quenta Silmarillion: Of the Eldar," delves into the history and significance of the elves in Middle-earth, shedding light on their pivotal role in the ongoing conflicts. "Akallabêth," the fourth part, shifts the narrative to the downfall of Númenor, an island kingdom, and the subsequent establishment of Gondor and Arnor by a group of loyal Númenóreans led by Elendil.

Finally, in the fifth part, "Of the Rings of Power and the Third Age," readers are introduced to the forging and distribution of the Rings of Power, along with the rise of the Dark Lord Sauron. This section sets the stage for the events that unfold in "The Lord of the Rings."

While "The Silmarillion: Volume 2" offers a fascinating and immersive experience for fans already well-versed in Tolkien's Middle-earth, it may prove challenging for newcomers or readers seeking a more straightforward narrative. The book delves into complex mythologies and details, requiring a degree of familiarity with the world and its history.

What are readers saying?

The second volume of J.R.R. Tolkien's epic creation, The Silmarillion, has garnered a wide range of opinions from readers. While some found it to be a worthy expansion of Tolkien's vast legendarium, others struggled with its dense and intricate narrative.

Many readers have praised the depth and richness of Tolkien's world-building in The Silmarillion Volume 2. They found his meticulous creation of mythology and history to be impressive, even likening the experience of reading it to delving into ancient texts or exploring a new religion. These readers appreciated the well-developed characters and engaging storytelling, which drew them into the immersive world of the book.

However, some readers found the structure and writing style of The Silmarillion Volume 2 to be challenging. They noted that it reads more like a historical account or encyclopedia rather than a traditional narrative, which hindered their ability to fully immerse themselves in the story. Additionally, the abundance of characters and unfamiliar names and places proved overwhelming for some readers.

Many readers emphasized that familiarity with Tolkien's other works, like The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, greatly enhanced their understanding and enjoyment of The Silmarillion Volume 2. They appreciated the interconnections between these different works and the way Tolkien expanded and deepened his mythology in this book.

Despite the extensive world-building and connections to Tolkien's previous works, one common criticism among readers was the lack of relatable or sympathetic characters. Some felt that the focus on historical events and divine beings left little room for emotional depth or character development, making it difficult to form a personal connection with the story.

#Silmarillion #Volume2 #Tolkien