The Television Sherlock Holmes : Book Review

"The Television Sherlock Holmes" by Peter Haining is an intriguing exploration of the world of Sherlock Holmes adaptations on television. Haining thoroughly examines the actors who have brought the iconic detective to life on screen, from Basil Rathbone to Jeremy Brett, and delves into the impact of their performances on the overall portrayal of Holmes. The book also provides a comprehensive look at the behind-the-scenes production aspects of these adaptations, shedding light on the evolution of Holmes on television.

Haining's extensive research and attention to detail are evident throughout the book. He takes readers on a journey through different eras of television, highlighting how advancements in technology influenced the visualization and storytelling of Sherlock Holmes adaptations. By offering insights into the challenges faced by the actors and producers, Haining captures the essence of each adaptation and helps readers understand the complexities of bringing Holmes to life on the small screen.

One of the strengths of this book is the inclusion of rare photographs and illustrations from the television adaptations. This visual element allows readers to get a glimpse into the world of Sherlock Holmes on television. Additionally, Haining incorporates behind-the-scenes anecdotes and interviews with key personnel involved in the productions, adding a layer of depth to the narrative and providing a well-rounded perspective on the challenges and successes of bringing Holmes to television.

Haining's writing style is engaging and accessible, making "The Television Sherlock Holmes" an enjoyable and informative read for both devoted Holmes fans and those with a general interest in television history. His passion for the subject matter shines through in his meticulous research and analysis, allowing readers to gain a deeper understanding and appreciation for the art of adapting Sherlock Holmes for the television medium.

In conclusion, "The Television Sherlock Holmes" is a comprehensive and captivating exploration of the various television adaptations of Sherlock Holmes. Haining's expertise and attention to detail make this book a must-read for any fan of the iconic detective and for enthusiasts of television history in general. It is an engaging and informative analysis that sheds light on the impact and evolution of Holmes on the small screen.

What are readers saying?

The book adaptation of the television series "The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes" by Jeremy Paul has garnered a range of reviews from readers on Goodreads. Jeremy Paul's novelization, based on the popular British series starring Jeremy Brett, has drawn both praise and criticism from readers.

Many reviewers commend Paul for his faithful portrayal of the source material, applauding his ability to capture the essence of the television series and create an engaging read. They appreciate how he brings the beloved characters, particularly Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson, to life and allows readers to relive the captivating stories from the show through the book.

However, not all readers share the same enthusiasm, expressing disappointment with the lack of originality in the book. They perceive it as simply a companion to the television series, lacking the inventiveness of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's original works. These readers argue that the book relies heavily on the popularity of the TV show and does not stand alone as a great work of literature.

The writing style is another aspect of the book that divides readers. Some appreciate Paul's ability to faithfully capture the dialogue and atmosphere of the television series, seamlessly extending the show's experience. On the other hand, some find the writing lackluster and inferior to Conan Doyle's original narratives. They highlight that the book lacks the depth and complexity of the original Holmes stories, failing to provide a fresh perspective on the well-known characters.

Despite the mixed reviews, most readers agree that the book can be an enjoyable read for fans of the television series. It offers a chance to revisit the beloved characters and stories that made "The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes" so popular. However, those seeking a truly original and captivating Holmes experience might find themselves disappointed by the book's dependence on the television adaptation, rather than offering new and exciting narratives.

SherlockHolmes TVSherlock LiteraryMystery