There Was a Cold Lady Who Swallowed Some Snow! : Book Review

"There Was a Cold Lady Who Swallowed Some Snow!" is an entertaining children's book that adds to the beloved "There Was an Old Lady" series. Written by Lucille Colandro, this delightful story follows a cold lady with an unusual appetite for winter and snow-related objects. As readers progress through the book, they'll find joy in predicting what the lady will swallow next and how it all comes together.

Colandro's storytelling style is engaging and playful, making it perfect for young children. The repetitive nature of the story allows children to actively participate by chanting along with each new item the lady swallows. The rhythmic flow of the text helps children follow and memorize the story, promoting reading skills and a love for language.

The illustrations by Jared Lee are vibrant and filled with humorous details. The colorful artwork brings the story to life and adds another layer of humor to the narrative. Children will be captivated by the illustrations, eagerly flipping through the pages to see what the cold lady will consume next.

In addition to its fun and silly storyline, "There Was a Cold Lady Who Swallowed Some Snow!" also offers educational value. It introduces young readers to winter-related objects and expands their vocabulary. The book also incorporates counting, as each item the lady swallows is numbered, providing a subtle learning opportunity.

Overall, Lucille Colandro's "There Was a Cold Lady Who Swallowed Some Snow!" is a playful and delightful children's book that will have young readers giggling and engaged. With its engaging storytelling, vibrant illustrations, and educational elements, this book is a fantastic addition to any child's library and is sure to be a favorite during storytime.

What are readers saying?

"There Was a Cold Lady Who Swallowed Some Snow" is a children's book penned by Lucille Colandro that tells the tale of a brave lady determined to brave the freezing weather and swallow some snow. This book has received a mix of reviews from readers, with some finding it delightful and captivating for young ones. They praise the vibrant illustrations and the repetitive nature of the story, which helps children easily follow along. Many parents appreciate how it helps their children learn about sequencing and rhyming words. Overall, these readers believe it's a fun read-aloud option for little ones.

However, there are some readers who have had concerns about the book. Some find the repetition in the story to be a bit tiresome and annoying, suggesting that the constant swallowing pattern becomes monotonous after a while. A few readers also feel that the storyline lacks substance and depth, and they hoped for more creativity and originality in the plot, as they found it somewhat predictable.

In addition, some reviewers note that while the book is enjoyable, it may not have as much educational value as they had hoped. They feel that it missed an opportunity to teach children about the consequences of certain actions or explore scientific concepts related to snow and winter. For these readers, the book falls short in providing a more enriching learning experience.

Despite the mixed opinions, many reviewers agree that the book has a certain charm and humor that children would enjoy. They mention the catchy rhymes and silly scenario as highlights, with several readers expressing how their children found the story amusing. Overall, "There Was a Cold Lady Who Swallowed Some Snow" seems to be a book that offers entertainment value for young children, but may not necessarily be a top choice for those seeking educational content.