This captivating and thought-provoking novel, "This is Not for You" by Jane Rule, delves into the intricacies of human relationships and the dynamics of love and desire. Set in 1960s Canada, the story revolves around Sophie, a married woman who forms a deep connection with a gay couple, Terry and Gerda. As their unconventional bond develops, the characters grapple with societal expectations, personal desires, and the constraints imposed by their roles and identities.
Jane Rule's writing is skillfully descriptive, immersing readers in the vivid world she has created. The characters are fully fleshed out, and their struggles feel genuine and relatable. Of the characters, Sophie stands out as a complex and sympathetic protagonist torn between her love and loyalty to her husband and her yearning for personal fulfillment.
A significant theme explored throughout the novel is the examination of different forms of love and relationships, particularly those that defy societal norms. Rule adeptly portrays the complexities and nuances of these relationships, shedding light on the challenges faced by individuals who deviate from traditional expectations. While romantic love is a key focus, the novel also emphasizes the importance of friendship and chosen family, offering an inclusive and refreshing perspective on the nature of love and human connection.
Available on Audible
In addition, Rule tackles issues of gender and sexuality, illustrating the struggles experienced by queer individuals in a society that frequently marginalizes and discriminates against them. By giving voice to characters like Terry and Gerda, who challenge societal expectations and defy conventional notions of love and sexuality, Rule encourages readers to question their own preconceived notions and expand their understanding.
"This is Not for You" is a poignant and thought-provoking read that delves into the complexities of relationships, societal expectations, and the transformative power of love. Jane Rule's beautiful writing and compelling characters take readers on a captivating journey, leaving them contemplative of their own beliefs and values.
What are readers saying?
Jane Rule's book "This Is Not For You" has received a mixed response from readers. Published in 1970, the novel delves into the themes of love, sexuality, and self-discovery through the perspectives of its characters.
Many readers praised Rule's writing style, describing it as poetic and mesmerizing. They were captivated by the beautiful prose and felt deeply connected to the emotions conveyed in the book. The author's ability to explore complex psychological and emotional landscapes was highly admired by those who enjoyed the novel.
However, some readers found the book slow-paced and confusing. They felt overwhelmed by the abundance of characters and struggled to form an intimate connection with them. Some reviewers also mentioned that the plot lacked depth and failed to provide a satisfying resolution for all the storylines. These readers found it difficult to fully engage with the book and felt disappointed by its execution.
The exploration of LGBT themes in the book was another aspect that divided readers. Some praised Rule's sensitive portrayal of diverse sexualities and found the representation important and groundbreaking for its time. They commended the author for addressing taboo subjects with compassion and honesty. On the other hand, some readers felt that the LGBT themes overshadowed the overall plot and inhibited their enjoyment of the book.
Despite the varying opinions, many readers appreciated the introspective nature of "This Is Not For You." They found it to be a thought-provoking read that delves into the complexities of human relationships and the intricacies of identity. The book sparked discussions on self-discovery, societal expectations, and the pursuit of personal happiness.
NotForYouBook SelfReflecting UnexpectedTwists