"This Side of Brightness" by Colum McCann is a beautifully written and captivating novel that skillfully intertwines the stories of two distinct eras in the history of New York City. Through the lives of Nathan Walker, a sandhog who toiled in the construction of subway tunnels in the early 1900s, and Treefrog, a homeless man surviving in the underground tunnels of present-day New York, McCann creates a rich and vivid portrayal of the city.
McCann's poetic language and descriptive prowess bring the characters and settings to life, immersing the reader in the gritty world of the sandhogs. We experience their struggles and triumphs, as well as their deep bonds of camaraderie. Simultaneously, we are confronted with the harsh reality of homelessness in modern society as Treefrog and others navigate the hidden tunnels beneath the city, forgotten and overlooked by the bustling metropolis above.
The novel delves into profound themes of identity, belonging, and the search for meaning in a hostile environment. McCann explores the lasting impact of our past experiences and how they shape our present circumstances. The characters in "This Side of Brightness" are complex and multi-dimensional, grappling with their personal demons while striving to find their place in society.
Available on Audible
The author's masterful storytelling engenders a sense of empathy and connection with the characters, allowing readers to appreciate their resilience and hope, even in the face of adversity. McCann's portrayal of New York City is sublime, capturing both its vibrant energy and its hidden depths. The contrast between the bustling world above ground and the clandestine labyrinth below is portrayed with vivid detail, enriching the overall narrative.
In conclusion, "This Side of Brightness" is a poignant and thought-provoking novel that highlights the depths of human resilience. Colum McCann's prose is simply stunning, immersing readers in a world that is as mesmerizing as it is harsh. With its strong sense of place and compelling characters, this novel is a must-read for lovers of literary fiction.
What are readers saying?
Colum McCann's novel "This Side of Brightness" has garnered a mixed reception from readers. The book consists of two distinct storylines set in different time periods: one delves into the lives of the men behind the construction of the Brooklyn Bridge in the late 1800s, while the other follows the struggles of a community of homeless individuals dwelling in underground tunnels in 1990s New York City.
Readers' reviews of "This Side of Brightness" often highlight McCann's adeptness at crafting vivid and atmospheric settings. Many commend the author for his rich and immersive descriptions, which effortlessly transport them to the bustling construction site of the iconic Brooklyn Bridge, as well as the gritty and harsh underground world of the homeless community. The meticulous attention to historical detail is also lauded by several reviewers.
However, some readers express disappointment with the book's plot and character development. They feel that McCann's dual narratives do not seamlessly merge, resulting in a disjointed reading experience. Critics note that the characters, particularly those in the contemporary storyline, lack depth and fail to emotionally engage the reader.
Nevertheless, other readers appreciate the novel's underlying social commentary. They applaud McCann for shedding light on important themes of social class struggles, homelessness, and marginalization within society. The juxtaposition of the lives of the bridge builders and the homeless population prompts readers to contemplate the evolving face of New York City over time.
In summary, opinions on "This Side of Brightness" are divided among readers. While some enjoy McCann's descriptive prose and the historical context, others find the plot and character development lacking. However, the book's exploration of societal issues is generally recognized and appreciated. Ultimately, the resonance of this novel will vary among readers, dependent upon their individual preferences and interests.
ThisSideOfBrightness BookReview LiteraryMasterpiece