Thud Ridge: F-105 Thunderchief missions over Vietnam : Book Review

"Thud Ridge" by Jack Broughton is an incredibly captivating memoir that offers a gripping firsthand account of the intense air combat during the Vietnam War. Broughton, a highly decorated fighter pilot, takes readers on an adrenaline-fueled journey as he recounts his experiences flying the F-105 Thunderchief, affectionately known as the "Thud," over enemy territory.

What separates "Thud Ridge" from other war memoirs is Broughton's ability to immerse readers in the chaotic and dangerous world of aerial warfare. His vivid descriptions and attention to detail make it feel as though we are right there in the cockpit with him, experiencing the thrill and danger of each mission. Broughton doesn't hold back in sharing the dangers faced by these brave pilots, as they pushed the limits of their aircraft while confronting North Vietnamese air defense systems.

One of the most striking aspects of the book is Broughton's honest portrayal of the emotional toll that war takes on pilots. He delves into the fear, anxiety, and grief that accompany their missions, emphasizing the psychological impact of combat. This adds a layer of depth to the narrative, allowing readers to gain a deeper understanding of the human side of warfare. It highlights the bravery and resilience required to endure such harrowing experiences.

Broughton's writing style is engaging and accessible, making it easy for both aviation enthusiasts and general readers to follow along. He effortlessly brings the events to life, keeping the reader eagerly turning the pages. He also takes the time to explain the technical aspects of flying and the intricacies of aerial combat in a manner that is easy to comprehend.

Overall, "Thud Ridge" is a remarkable memoir that provides an unfiltered look into the harrowing realities of war from a fighter pilot's perspective. Broughton's bravery and resilience shine through his writing, making this book a must-read for anyone interested in military history or aviation. It serves as a powerful reminder of the sacrifices made by those who serve in the armed forces.

What are readers saying?

Thud Ridge, authored by Jack Broughton, has garnered a variety of responses from readers. This book presents a personal narrative of the author's time as an Air Force pilot during the Vietnam War. While some readers found the memoir to be enthralling and enlightening, others believed it lacked depth and failed to provide a comprehensive account of the war itself.

Numerous readers commended Broughton's engaging writing style and his ability to vividly capture the intense world of combat aviation. They appreciated his firsthand perspective, finding his anecdotes and descriptions to be captivating. Many admired Broughton's bravery and dedication to his fellow soldiers, viewing Thud Ridge as an authentic and riveting glimpse into the challenges and sacrifices faced by military personnel during the Vietnam War.

However, some readers were dissatisfied with the book, as they felt it did not delve deep enough into the analysis or historical context they expected. They desired more background information to better comprehend the political and social aspects of the war. Additionally, several reviewers criticized Broughton's writing style, claiming it was at times disjointed and repetitive, which hindered their overall enjoyment of the book.

Furthermore, a few readers voiced concerns about the book's biased perspective. They felt that Broughton's portrayal of the Vietnamese people lacked empathy and presented only one side of the story. These readers desired a more balanced and nuanced examination of the war, including the experiences and perspectives of the Vietnamese population.

In conclusion, Thud Ridge by Jack Broughton has received a range of responses. While some readers found it to be a captivating and authentic memoir, others felt it lacked depth and balance. Overall, the book offers a personal account of the author's experiences as an Air Force pilot during the Vietnam War, but it may not fully satisfy readers seeking a comprehensive understanding of the conflict.

ThudRidgeBook VietnamWar PilotMemoir