To Remain an Indian: Lessons in Democracy from a Century of Native American Education : Book Review

"To Remain an Indian" by K. Tsianina Lomawaima is a profound and thought-provoking exploration of the repercussions of federal policies on Native American communities. Focusing on the experiences of the Hopi and Navajo tribes in Arizona, the book delves into the complex history of assimilation efforts in the United States. Lomawaima challenges the idea that assimilation was a well-intentioned process, shedding light on the deep-seated prejudices and injustices that arose as a result.

The author presents a meticulously researched account of the forced removal of Hopi and Navajo children from their families and their placement in government-run Indian boarding schools. Through eloquent storytelling, Lomawaima artfully explores the long-lasting effects of this traumatic experience on individuals and their communities, highlighting the remarkable resilience and strength displayed by Native people in the face of oppression.

Additionally, Lomawaima delves into the intricate dynamics of cultural heritage and its role in preserving a distinct tribal identity. Drawing on personal narratives and historical analysis, the author effectively demonstrates the profound connection between land, language, and culture. By doing so, she emphasizes the detrimental consequences of forcibly stripping Native Americans of these fundamental aspects of their identity.

One of the notable strengths of "To Remain an Indian" is Lomawaima's ability to approach difficult subjects with objectivity and compassion. She not only explores the negative ramifications of assimilation policies, but also recognizes and celebrates the agency and resistance exhibited by Native communities. In doing so, the book serves as a powerful reminder of the ongoing struggles faced by Native Americans and underscores the significance of safeguarding their cultural heritage.

Overall, "To Remain an Indian" is a thought-provoking and comprehensive examination of the impact of assimilation policies on Native American communities. Lomawaima's meticulous research and compassionate storytelling shed light on a dark aspect of American history, and ultimately highlight the resilience and strength of indigenous peoples. This book is a must-read for those seeking a deeper understanding of the ongoing struggles and triumphs of Native American communities.

What are readers saying?

"To Remain an Indian" by K. Tsianina Lomawaima has garnered positive reception from readers for its profound exploration of Indigenous boarding school survivors' experiences and the assimilation policies imposed on Native American communities in the United States.

The book has been commended for its meticulous research and extensive documentation of personal stories that shed light on the long-lasting effects of the boarding school system. Lomawaima's dedication to giving a voice to the survivors and honoring their resilience in the face of cultural oppression has been particularly appreciated. Furthermore, the book's engaging writing style has made it accessible to a wide range of readers.

Readers have found immense educational value in "To Remain an Indian," as it offers crucial insights into the history of Native American boarding schools and their impact on generations of Indigenous peoples. The author's thought-provoking analysis and interpretation of historical events have been considered significant contributions to the ongoing discussions on decolonization and Indigenous rights.

The book has been praised for accurately portraying the political and cultural struggles faced by Native Americans, thus promoting empathy and understanding among non-Indigenous audiences. It has been noted that Lomawaima's depiction is valuable in building bridges and fostering reconciliation.

While the majority of reviews express admiration for Lomawaima's work, it should be noted that a few readers have mentioned the emotional challenges that arise from the exploration of trauma and loss in the book. However, they also emphasize the importance of confronting this painful history as a means of promoting healing and reconciliation.

IndigenousIdentity CulturalHeritage NativePride