Tolkien and Modernity 1 : Book Review

In "Tolkien and Modernity" by Thomas Honegger, readers are taken on a captivating journey into the intricate connection between J.R.R. Tolkien's literary works and the modern world. Honegger skillfully explores how Tolkien's writings both engage with and resist the cultural and social changes of the twentieth century, offering readers a fresh and enlightening perspective on this renowned author.

The book starts by delving into Tolkien's personal experiences during World War I and how they influenced the creation of his fantastical realm, Middle-earth. Honegger uncovers the impact of war trauma on Tolkien's imagination, shedding light on the dark undercurrents present in his works. Through a meticulous analysis of Tolkien's texts, the author uncovers how the author grappled with the realities of modern warfare while constructing his own unique mythological landscape.

Honegger goes on to explore Tolkien's attitudes towards industrialization and technological progress, emphasizing his mixed feelings towards modernity. The author uncovers how Tolkien's portrayal of the natural world and his rejection of industrialization reflect his concerns about the dehumanizing effects of modernity and the loss of a simpler, more authentic way of life. This investigation deepens our understanding of Tolkien's environmentalism and his critique of the excesses of industrial society.

Additionally, the book tackles the question of gender in Tolkien's works. Honegger carefully examines the criticism surrounding Tolkien's portrayal of female characters, noting the limited scope and stereotypes. However, the author also offers a nuanced analysis, considering how Tolkien's perspective on gender was influenced by his own cultural and historical context, highlighting that his writings can both conform to and challenge prevailing gender norms of the time.

Overall, "Tolkien and Modernity" provides readers with a thought-provoking exploration of the intertwining relationship between Tolkien's works and the modern world. Honegger's thorough research and insightful analysis shed new light on the complexities of Tolkien's writing, exposing readers to a deeper understanding of his themes and intentions. This book is an essential read for Tolkien enthusiasts and scholars interested in the fascinating intersection of literature and modernity.

What are readers saying?

"Tolkien and Modernity" by Thomas Honegger is a thought-provoking exploration of J.R.R. Tolkien's writings and how they relate to the modern world. The reception of the book has been mixed, with some appreciating its thorough analysis and others finding it too academic.

Many reviewers praised Honegger's in-depth understanding of Tolkien's works and his ability to dissect the complex themes within the context of modernity. They found his exploration of the relevance of Tolkien's writings to contemporary issues, such as environmentalism and technology, to be fascinating and insightful. Readers also commended Honegger for going beyond the well-known "Lord of the Rings" trilogy and delving into lesser-known aspects of Tolkien's works.

However, some reviewers felt that Honegger's scholarly approach made the book too inaccessible for casual readers. They found the writing style overly complex and the analysis too specialized, which hindered their understanding and enjoyment of the book. These readers suggested that the content would be better suited for scholars or individuals with a comprehensive knowledge of Tolkien's works.

Additionally, a few reviewers mentioned that the book lacked a clear structure, making it difficult to follow the author's arguments. They felt that Honegger could have organized the content in a more coherent manner, allowing readers to navigate the complex concepts with greater ease.

Despite these criticisms, many readers found "Tolkien and Modernity" to be a valuable contribution to the study of Tolkien's works. They appreciated how Honegger effectively connected different ideas, showcasing the continued relevance of Tolkien's ideas in the modern world.

TolkienAndModernity1 TolkienScholarship JRRtolkien