Tolkien and Shakespeare: Essays on Shared Themes and Language : Book Review

In her book "Tolkien and Shakespeare," Janet Brennan Croft explores the fascinating interconnections and influences between two literary giants, J.R.R. Tolkien and William Shakespeare. By delving into the intricate parallels, thematic similarities, and shared elements in their works, Croft offers readers an essential read for both Tolkien and Shakespeare aficionados.

Croft skillfully dissects how Tolkien drew inspiration from Shakespeare's plays, highlighting the influence of the Bard's language, characters, and storytelling techniques on Tolkien's own writing. Through meticulous analysis, she reveals how Tolkien's admiration for Shakespeare permeates his works, elevating his fantastical creations with greater depth and richness.

A significant strength of this book lies in Croft's comprehensive exploration of the literary, linguistic, and mythological connections between Tolkien and Shakespeare. Drawing upon an extensive range of sources and scholarship, she weaves together a captivating narrative, ensuring readers gain a thorough understanding of the linkages between these two literary icons.

In addition to its scholarly aspects, "Tolkien and Shakespeare" provides a highly accessible reading experience. Croft's writing style is clear, concise, and engaging, making it suitable for both academics and casual readers alike. The book strikes a perfect balance between rigorous analysis and approachability, guaranteeing its appeal to a wide audience.

Overall, "Tolkien and Shakespeare" is a thought-provoking and enlightening exploration of the connections between two literary legends. Janet Brennan Croft's thorough research, coupled with her clear and engaging writing style, makes this book an invaluable resource for anyone interested in understanding the deep-rooted links between Tolkien and Shakespeare's works. Whether you are a scholar, a fan of Tolkien or Shakespeare, or simply curious about the literary influences that shape our favorite authors, this book is a must-read.

What are readers saying?

Janet Brennan Croft's book "Tolkien and Shakespeare" has received predominantly positive reviews, with readers commending the author's insightful exploration of the connections and influences between J.R.R. Tolkien and William Shakespeare. Reviewers particularly appreciate the extensive research undertaken by Croft, praising her well-supported arguments and ample evidence from both authors' works. This attention to detail enhances readers' comprehension of the similarities and influences shared by these literary titans.

The reviews also emphasize Croft's ability to make the subject matter accessible to both scholars and casual fans. By striking a balance between academic rigor and engaging storytelling, she allows readers to delve into the connections between Tolkien and Shakespeare without feeling overwhelmed. The book's organization and structure receive praise as well, as the chapters are well-organized, each focusing on specific aspects of the comparison. This aids readers in following along and gaining a comprehensive understanding of the parallels between the two authors.

Additionally, several reviewers find the overarching theme of myth intriguing and expertly explored throughout the book. These readers appreciate how Croft delves into how both Tolkien and Shakespeare incorporate myth into their works.

Overall, readers applaud Janet Brennan Croft for her thorough research, accessible writing style, and thought-provoking insights into the parallels between these renowned authors. This book serves as an illuminating and enjoyable read, deepening readers' appreciation for the works of Tolkien and Shakespeare, regardless of whether they are fans of one author, the other, or both.