Tolkien & the Silmarillion : Book Review

"Clyde S. Kilby's book, "Tolkien: The Silmarillion," presents readers with a comprehensive and insightful examination of J.R.R. Tolkien's iconic work of literature, "The Silmarillion." Kilby, a well-respected scholar of Tolkien's writings, invites readers on a deep and enlightening journey into the complexities of this epic mythology, providing invaluable insights into the creation, themes, and characters unearthed within Tolkien's imaginative world.

In the opening pages, Kilby sets the stage by emphasizing the significance of "The Silmarillion" within the larger scope of Tolkien's legendarium. He artfully explores the mythological origins and overarching narrative structure of the book, illuminating its interconnectedness with other renowned works in Tolkien's Middle-earth canon. Through meticulous analysis, Kilby reveals the profound symbolism and themes that lie beneath the surface of this intricate tapestry of tales.

One of the true strengths of Kilby's book is his deep exploration of the diverse cast of characters that populate "The Silmarillion." While paying due attention to the major figures such as Morgoth, Fëanor, and Melkor, Kilby also unveils the significance and contributions of lesser-known heroes and heroines. By delving into their motivations, relationships, and impact on the overarching narrative, Kilby provides fresh perspectives that enhance the reader's understanding and appreciation of Tolkien's masterful storytelling.

Furthermore, Kilby places a strong emphasis on the importance of language and linguistics in Tolkien's creation. He delves into the intricate evolution of Tolkien's invented languages, revealing how these linguistic elements shape the very essence of Middle-earth. Through this exploration, Kilby adds a layer of depth and nuance to the reader's comprehension of the meticulously crafted world Tolkien has created.

Throughout the book, Kilby skillfully combines his vast knowledge of Tolkien's works with his own insightful analysis. His writing style is accessible, appealing to both scholars and casual readers alike who seek a deeper understanding of "The Silmarillion." In essence, "Tolkien: The Silmarillion" serves as an indispensable companion to Tolkien's masterpiece, offering a holistic and engaging exploration of the themes, characters, and linguistic intricacies found within its pages. Kilby's work truly illuminates the brilliance and timeless allure of Tolkien's enchanting world."

What are readers saying?

Clyde S. Kilby's book "Tolkien: The Silmarillion" has garnered a diverse range of reviews from readers. While some commend Kilby's insightful analysis of J.R.R. Tolkien's renowned work, others feel that the book falls short of their expectations.

Many readers appreciate Kilby's profound understanding of Tolkien's universe and his ability to effectively convey the intricacies of "The Silmarillion." They admire his exploration of the book's themes, characters, and mythology, which adds depth and clarity to the reading experience. Kilby's expertise on Tolkien's life and influences also shines through, providing readers with valuable context and background information.

However, some reviewers express disappointment with Kilby's writing style. They find his analysis dry and academic, making it challenging to engage with the material. Critics argue that the book lacks the storytelling and narrative flow they were hoping for, making it a difficult read for those unfamiliar with "The Silmarillion."

Several readers appreciate Kilby's inclusion of Tolkien's original drafts and unpublished writings, as it offers a unique perspective on the creation of "The Silmarillion." These additional materials provide insight into Tolkien's thought process and allow readers to delve deeper into the intricacies of his work.

On the other hand, a few reviewers criticize Kilby's organization and structure. They find the book disjointed, which makes it hard to follow the progression of ideas. Some readers also feel that Kilby focuses too heavily on specific aspects of the book, neglecting others that they would have liked to see explored further.

#TheSilmarillion #Tolkien #EpicFantasy