Tolkien's Modern Middle Ages : Book Review

"Tolkien's Modern Middle Ages" by Jane Chance is a captivating and thought-provoking book that presents an insightful analysis of J.R.R. Tolkien's work from a medievalist perspective. Chance skillfully explores the deep connections between Tolkien's writings and the medieval literature and culture that influenced him, offering a fresh and nuanced perspective on his iconic works.

One of the standout aspects of this book is Chance's ability to draw intricate connections between Tolkien's Middle-earth and the medieval world that served as its foundation. Through meticulous research and analysis, she uncovers how Tolkien expertly incorporated elements of Old English, Norse sagas, and Arthurian legends into the narrative of "The Lord of the Rings." By exploring linguistic and thematic links, Chance reveals how Tolkien blended the medieval past with his own imaginative vision, creating a rich and engrossing mythical world.

Another noteworthy aspect of Chance's work is her examination of heroism and gender in Tolkien's writings. By delving into the roles and representations of both male and female characters, she reveals Tolkien's subversion of traditional gender norms and stereotypes. This nuanced exploration adds depth to our understanding of Tolkien's portrayal of heroism and gender dynamics, highlighting the progressive elements within his writing.

Chance also delves into the concept of medievalism in a modern context, shedding light on how Tolkien's work influenced the fantasy genre as a whole. She explores the impact of his world-building and the enduring legacy of Middle-earth, which continues to captivate readers and inspire subsequent generations of writers. Through her engaging analysis, Chance demonstrates the ongoing relevance and importance of Tolkien's medievalist approach.

In conclusion, "Tolkien's Modern Middle Ages" is a must-read for fans of J.R.R. Tolkien's work and scholars of medieval literature alike. Jane Chance's insightful exploration offers fresh perspectives and interpretations, shedding new light on the connections between Tolkien's fantasy world and the medieval past. With its well-researched and eloquently written essays, this book serves as an essential resource for anyone interested in the lasting impact of Tolkien and the medieval influences that shaped his extraordinary works.

What are readers saying?

"Tolkien's Modern Middle Ages" by Jane Chance has garnered a variety of reviews from readers, expressing differing opinions on the book's merits. This work delves into how J.R.R. Tolkien's writings, particularly "The Lord of the Rings" and "The Hobbit," were influenced by medieval literature and history. While some readers found the book to be an insightful and well-researched exploration, others encountered difficulties in its dense and intricate nature.

Numerous reviewers commended the thorough analysis and scholarly approach presented by Chance. They appreciated the depth of her research and the connections she drew between Tolkien's works and their medieval counterparts. These readers found the book to be an invaluable resource when it came to understanding the historical context of Tolkien's writings. Additionally, they enjoyed the exploration of themes such as chivalry, mythology, and linguistics. Chance's engaging writing style, along with her ability to merge various sources and perspectives, further contributed to the book's appeal.

On the other hand, some readers struggled with the book's academic tone and complexity. They felt that the extensive use of references and the overall scholarly nature of the book made it less accessible to those without prior knowledge in medieval studies. These readers desired a more concise and approachable writing style. Additionally, some found the book's organization to be confusing, as it occasionally lacked clarity in presenting the author's arguments.

In essence, Jane Chance's "Tolkien's Modern Middle Ages" provides an intricate examination of the medieval influences embedded within J.R.R. Tolkien's works. Readers with a scholarly inclination appreciate the depth of research and the academic style employed. However, others may find the book's complexity challenging, wishing for a more reader-friendly approach. Consequently, this book serves as a valuable resource for those interested in Tolkien's writings and their historical context. Nevertheless, casual readers or individuals without prior knowledge in medieval literature and history may find it less accessible or engaging.