Tombstone: An Iliad of the Southwest : Book Review

"Tombstone" by Walter Noble Burns is an incredibly captivating and comprehensive account of the notorious town in the Old West. The book delves deep into the history of Tombstone, Arizona, bringing to life the lawless and unpredictable nature of the town during its heyday. Burns's meticulous research and engaging storytelling create a vivid and detailed picture of the town and its inhabitants.

What sets Burns's book apart is his ability to humanize the historical figures who played significant roles in Tombstone's history. Characters such as the Earp brothers and the Clantons are given depth and dimension, moving beyond their legendary status to become real people with their own motivations and flaws. By exploring their backgrounds and experiences, Burns helps readers understand the complex dynamics that contributed to the violence and tensions in the town.

In addition to individual character studies, Burns provides a broader social and historical context for the events in Tombstone. He examines the influence of mining on the town's growth, the conflicts between cattle ranchers and mining interests, and the interactions between law enforcement and the criminal element. This wider perspective enriches the narrative and helps readers grasp the underlying factors that shaped Tombstone's history.

Furthermore, Burns's writing style is both engaging and accessible, making the book a delight to read for history enthusiasts and casual readers alike. Though a work of nonfiction, "Tombstone" reads like a gripping novel, with its well-crafted scenes and dramatic storytelling. Burns excels at creating suspense and building tension, keeping readers enthralled from beginning to end.

In conclusion, "Tombstone" by Walter Noble Burns is a compelling and thoroughly researched account of one of the most infamous towns in the Old West. With its vivid descriptions, memorable characters, and engaging storytelling, this book offers a fascinating exploration of Tombstone's history and the individuals who shaped its legacy. Whether you have a passion for history or simply enjoy Wild West tales, "Tombstone" is an absolute must-read.

What are readers saying?

Walter Noble Burns's book 'Tombstone' has elicited a range of responses from readers, with mixed reviews surfacing. The general consensus is that the book offers a wealth of information about the events that unfolded in Tombstone, Arizona during the late 1800s. However, some readers felt that the author's writing style lacked excitement and failed to captivate their interest.

One prevailing theme among positive reviews is that 'Tombstone' provides a meticulous and extensively researched account of the town's history. Readers commended the author's attention to detail and the abundant information included in the book. Many found it to be an educational read, particularly relishing the opportunity to delve into the famous gunfight at the O.K. Corral and the intriguing personalities intertwined with it.

Nonetheless, a subset of readers found the writing style to be somewhat dry, lacking energy, and resembling a historical report rather than a gripping narrative. While they acknowledged the value of the information presented, it failed to engage them fully or create an immersive reading experience.

Another critique voiced by certain readers was the dearth of character development. They desired a deeper exploration of the individuals involved, asserting that the focus on events overshadowed the personal motivations and complexities of the individuals. These readers yearned for a more intimate and emotive encounter with the book's subjects.

Despite these criticisms, others admired the straightforward and factual approach taken by 'Tombstone.' They lauded the author's commitment to presenting an accurate historical account without embellishments, viewing the book as a valuable resource for historical research.

TombstoneBook WesternReads WildWestLiterature