Tribes: How Race, Religion and Identity Determine Success in the New Global Economy : Book Review

In his book "Tribes: How Race, Religion, and Identity Determine Success in the New Global Economy," Joel Kotkin explores how our social and cultural identities influence our lives and shape the future of global economies. He argues that humans have an innate need to belong to a group or tribe, and these tribes play a crucial role in shaping economic, political, and social landscapes.

Kotkin emphasizes the importance of understanding the influence of different tribes in our interconnected world. He analyzes the role of race, religion, and other cultural factors in determining success, wealth, and power. By examining examples from Europe, Asia, and the United States, Kotkin provides a comprehensive analysis of the economic strategies employed by various tribes.

One key concept discussed in the book is the distinction between "strong" and "weak" tribes and their ability to adapt and thrive in the global economy. Kotkin argues that tribes with a strong sense of identity and cohesion are better positioned for success both economically and politically. He explores how strong tribes create economic communities and networks, leading to increased opportunities and prosperity.

Additionally, Kotkin delves into the impact of migration and globalization on tribal identities. He emphasizes the need to strike a balance between preserving cultural heritage and embracing diversity. By understanding the dynamics of tribalism, Kotkin believes we can navigate the challenges and opportunities of globalization more effectively.

Overall, "Tribes" offers insightful observations on the role of social and cultural identities in shaping the future of the global economy. Kotkin's analysis provides a thought-provoking perspective on the influence of tribes, urging readers to consider the impact of race, religion, and cultural identity in our increasingly interconnected world.

What are readers saying?

In his book "Tribes: How Race, Religion, and Identity Determine Success in the New Global Economy," Joel Kotkin examines the impact of tribalism on various aspects of society. This insightful book has received a range of reviews, with some readers praising its exploration of identity in today's global economy, while others critique its oversimplified analysis.

Many readers appreciate Kotkin's ability to delve into the complexity of tribalism. They find his examination of how race, religion, and identity influence success in the global economy to be thought-provoking and enlightening. Kotkin supports his arguments with diverse case studies and examples, making the book engaging and relatable for those interested in sociology and economics.

However, some reviewers express disappointment with the book's oversimplification of the subject matter. Critics argue that Kotkin relies too heavily on generalizations and fails to consider the nuances and cultural differences found in individual experiences. They believe that this broad approach weakens his arguments and makes them less convincing.

The writing style of "Tribes" also receives mixed reviews. While some readers find Kotkin's prose clear and concise, allowing for easy comprehension of the subject matter, others find it repetitive and excessively academic. Some reviewers suggest that a more engaging and accessible writing style could have broadened the book's appeal to a wider audience.

Opinions also differ on the book's overall structure and organization. Some readers appreciate Kotkin's logical presentation of arguments, with each chapter building upon the previous one. Others, however, feel that the book lacks cohesion and jumps between topics without a clear overarching narrative, making it challenging to follow.

TribesBook Leadership CommunityBuilding