Un)Doing the Missionary Position: Gender Asymmetry in Contemporary Asian American Women's Writing : Book Review

"Un-Doing the Missionary Position" by Phillipa Kafka presents a thought-provoking critique of traditional missionary work and its power dynamics. Kafka delves into the assumptions, methods, and impacts of missionary work, challenging its effectiveness and emphasizing its potential harms. Through personal anecdotes, historical examples, and theoretical discussions, Kafka encourages readers to reexamine their own beliefs and approaches to global engagement.

One of the central themes of the book is the perpetuation of inequality and colonialist ideologies within missionary work. Kafka argues that the traditional missionary position often places Western practitioners in a position of superiority and views the recipients as inferior, leading to a power imbalance and cultural imposition. Instead, she advocates for reciprocal relationships that value local communities and the agency and wisdom they possess.

Religious conversion is another complex topic that Kafka delves into. She critiques the use of economic and social incentives to induce individuals to convert, as well as the problematic notion of "saving souls" without respecting existing belief systems. By examining historical cases and drawing on diverse cultural perspectives, Kafka emphasizes the need for more respectful and inclusive approaches to religious conversion.

Throughout the book, Kafka underscores the importance of self-reflection and humility for those engaged in missionary work. She urges readers to critically examine their biases, privileges, and intentions, highlighting the potential for unintended harm. By promoting a more self-aware and empathetic approach, Kafka believes that missionary work can be transformed into a responsible and authentic endeavor that genuinely supports the well-being and autonomy of those being served.

In conclusion, "Un-Doing the Missionary Position" offers a profound and challenging perspective on missionary work. Phillipa Kafka's analysis prompts readers to reevaluate power dynamics, assumptions, and impacts associated with traditional missionary practices. By sharing personal stories, historical examples, and theoretical insights, Kafka advocates for a more respectful, inclusive, and self-reflective approach that prioritizes the agency and dignity of those being served. This book serves as a valuable resource for individuals interested in understanding and improving global engagement.

What are readers saying?

"Un-Doing the Missionary Position" by Phillipa Kafka has received a range of reviews, showcasing diverse opinions and emotions from readers. The book delves into the author's personal journey of challenging stereotypes and expectations associated with missionary work.

Some reviewers applauded Kafka for her candid and introspective storytelling, praising her honesty and vulnerability. They found her exploration of the complexities and challenges of missionary work to be valuable, appreciating her direct confrontation of misconceptions and stereotypes. These readers were engaged by Kafka's writing style and felt that she provided valuable insights.

However, not all readers were satisfied with "Un-Doing the Missionary Position." Some criticized Kafka for focusing excessively on her personal experiences, lacking a broader perspective on the topic. They felt that the book lacked depth and failed to provide a comprehensive understanding of the varied issues surrounding missionary work.

Furthermore, some found Kafka's writing style confusing and disjointed, struggling to connect with her narrative. These readers felt that the book lacked a clear structure or direction, leaving them dissatisfied with their reading experience.

On the other hand, many readers appreciated the book's thought-provoking nature. They found Kafka's exploration of the cultural, religious, and ethical implications of missionary work to be compelling and stimulating. These readers commended the author for raising important questions and challenging established beliefs.

UnDoingTheMissionaryPosition DeconstructingMissionaryPosition ChallengingNorms