Up from Methodism: A Memoir of a Man Gone to the Devil : Book Review

"Up from Methodism" written by Herbert Asbury offers readers a captivating and thought-provoking exploration of religious upbringing and personal growth. Through vivid storytelling and honest introspection, Asbury takes us on a journey from his devout Methodist upbringing in the early 20th century to his transformation into a questioning and independent thinker.

One of the strengths of this memoir lies in Asbury's ability to vividly capture the essence of his religious background and its profound impact on him. His descriptions of his childhood experiences, church rituals, and interactions with fellow Methodists provide a rich backdrop for understanding his subsequent struggles and personal transformations. Asbury's writing style is engaging and accessible, inviting readers to easily connect with his story.

The book delves into the conflicts and doubts that arise as Asbury begins to question his faith and confront the limitations of his religious teachings. This introspective journey is relatable for those who have undergone a similar evolution in their own beliefs, while also providing illuminating insights for readers unfamiliar with the challenges faced when questioning one's religious upbringing.

Asbury's narrative goes beyond leaving Methodism behind; it also encompasses a quest for personal truth and meaning. Through his experiences, he explores different belief systems and philosophies, ultimately developing his own unique worldview. This exploration of diverse perspectives demonstrates his willingness to engage with ideas beyond his comfort zone, adding depth and intellectual curiosity to the narrative.

Overall, "Up from Methodism" is a captivating book that offers valuable insights into the complexities of religious upbringing and personal growth. Asbury's candid reflections and compelling storytelling make for an engaging read that appeals to a broad audience. Whether readers have grappled with their own religious beliefs or are simply interested in exploring different perspectives, this memoir provides a thought-provoking and enriching experience.

What are readers saying?

"Up from Methodism" by Herbert Asbury has received a range of reviews from readers, with both praise and criticism. The book delves into Asbury's upbringing in a strict Methodist family and his subsequent departure from the religion, prompting mixed reactions from readers.

Some readers admired Asbury's candidness and found his personal story relatable, appreciating his frankness about the challenges he faced growing up in a conservative religious community. They found the book to be a thought-provoking exploration of religious identity and personal growth, drawing them in with its compelling narrative.

However, others were disappointed with the book, expressing their dissatisfaction with its lack of depth and coherence. They felt that Asbury failed to fully explore the complexities of his journey away from Methodism, and that the book lacked a clear structure. These readers desired a more thorough examination of the author's religious transformation.

Furthermore, some readers felt that the book deviated too much from its initial premise. They thought that Asbury dedicated excessive attention to historical events and societal issues, detracting from his personal experiences. These readers yearned for a more introspective exploration that would allow them to better connect with the author's story.

Despite these criticisms, many readers still found value in "Up from Methodism." They admired Asbury's storytelling abilities, praising his skill in vividly portraying the time and place of his upbringing. They commended his honesty in sharing his personal struggles and found the narrative engaging and entertaining.

UpFromMethodism BookRecommendation SpiritualJourney