Upper West Side Story: A History and Guide : Book Review

"Upper West Side Story" by Peter Salwen is a captivating memoir that takes readers on an intimate exploration of New York City's iconic Upper West Side neighborhood. Through his personal experiences and reflections, Salwen offers a unique and engaging journey through the vibrant streets of this famous area.

One of the book's strengths is Salwen's ability to intertwine historical context with his own anecdotes. He expertly weaves tales of well-known figures who have called the Upper West Side home, from artists and writers to musicians and activists. Through these stories, he presents a vivid and dynamic portrait of the diverse community that has shaped the neighborhood over the years.

What truly sets this book apart is Salwen's masterful capture of the Upper West Side's charm and character. His writing is engaging, witty, and filled with vivid descriptions that transport readers to the busy streets of the neighborhood. Salwen's love for the area shines through in every page, making it effortless for readers to immerse themselves in his memories and experiences.

Beyond the engaging storytelling, "Upper West Side Story" delves into deeper themes such as gentrification, social change, and the challenges of city life. Salwen offers thought-provoking insights and perspectives, inviting readers to reflect on the impact of urban development and the constant evolution of neighborhoods.

Overall, "Upper West Side Story" is a must-read for anyone interested in the history and culture of New York City. Salwen's memoir is a delightful mix of nostalgia, humor, and astute observations, creating a captivating and enjoyable journey through both the streets and lives of the Upper West Side.

What are readers saying?

"Upper West Side Story" by Peter Salwen has garnered varied opinions from readers. Some reviewers commended the book for its unique perspective on New York City's Upper West Side, praising Salwen's ability to vividly bring the neighborhood to life. They enjoyed his storytelling and found his descriptions engaging, providing an enjoyable glimpse into the area's history and culture.

On the other hand, there were readers who found the book lacking in depth and coherence. They felt that Salwen's writing style was disjointed and made it difficult to follow the narrative. In addition, some reviewers observed that the book lacked a clear central theme or message, ultimately leading to an inconsistent reading experience.

Critics also noted that the book appeared to focus more on Salwen's personal experiences and opinions rather than offering a comprehensive exploration of the Upper West Side. This left some readers feeling detached, as they had hoped for a more well-rounded portrayal of the neighborhood.

Despite these mixed opinions, most readers agreed on Salwen's evident love for the Upper West Side. They acknowledged his deep knowledge and affection for the subject matter, even if they had their criticisms of the book.

In summary, "Upper West Side Story" received a range of reviews from readers. While some appreciated Salwen's storytelling and vivid descriptions, others found the book lacking in depth and coherence. If you have a specific interest in the Upper West Side or are curious about one person's perspective on this iconic neighborhood, it may be worth exploring this book.

UpperWestSideStory NYCReads CityTales