Victorian Masculinities: Manhood and Masculine Poetics in Early Victorian Literature and Art : Book Review

In "Victorian Masculinities," Herbert L. Sussman provides a detailed examination of the multifaceted nature of masculinity during the Victorian era. Throughout the book, Sussman explores the various dimensions of masculinity, tracing how it was constructed and performed within different contexts.

The book begins by establishing the historical and cultural backdrop of the Victorian era, shedding light on the societal expectations and norms that shaped masculine identity. Sussman explores the impact of factors such as the rise of the middle class and the influence of industrialization, which played a significant role in shaping Victorian masculinity. Moreover, he examines how masculinity intersected with elements like race, class, and sexuality, offering a nuanced understanding of the diverse experiences of men during this time.

Sussman delves into several themes associated with Victorian masculinity throughout the book. He examines the pressures imposed on men to conform to ideals of stoicism, self-control, and being a "gentleman," revealing the impact of these ideals on men's mental and emotional well-being. Sussman highlights the hidden vulnerabilities and anxieties experienced by Victorian men, shedding light on aspects of masculinity that are often overlooked.

One of the strengths of Sussman's analysis is his incorporation of cultural texts and representations into his research. By analyzing works by renowned authors such as Charles Dickens and Thomas Hardy, as well as visual representations of masculinity, Sussman demonstrates how these cultural products simultaneously reinforced and challenged prevailing notions of Victorian masculinity.

"Victorian Masculinities" offers a deep and enlightening exploration of a complex subject. Sussman's meticulous research and insightful analysis make this book a valuable resource for scholars and anyone seeking to gain a comprehensive understanding of masculinity in the Victorian era.

What are readers saying?

Herbert L. Sussman's book "Victorian Masculinities" has received a mixed response from readers. While some have found it to be a valuable resource that sheds light on the complexity of masculinity during the Victorian era, others believe it lacks depth and fails to provide new insights.

One reviewer commended Sussman for his thorough research and thoughtful analysis of various aspects of Victorian masculinity. They appreciated his exploration of gender roles, sexuality, and the influence of societal norms, as well as his use of primary sources to support his arguments.

However, not all readers were impressed with the book. Some critics found Sussman's writing dense and overly academic, making it challenging to engage with the material. They also felt the book lacked a clear structure and struggled to maintain a cohesive narrative, which affected their reading experience.

Another area of contention among reviewers was the absence of fresh perspectives or original insights in Sussman's work. Some readers felt that the book largely rehashed existing scholarship on Victorian masculinity without adding anything new. They were disappointed by the lack of innovative ideas or analysis that could have enhanced their understanding of the topic.

On a positive note, many readers appreciated Sussman's inclusive approach in examining Victorian masculinity. They noted that he explored the complexities of class, race, and sexuality within the context of masculinity, offering a more diverse and inclusive perspective.

VictorianMasculinities ClassicLiterature GenderStudies