"Waiting for Foucault, Still" is a captivating book written by Marshall Sahlins that delves deep into the intricate connection between cultural anthropology and the renowned French philosopher, Michel Foucault. Sahlins explores the profound impact of Foucault's ideas on anthropology, analyzing how they challenged and eventually influenced the field. The book follows Sahlins' intellectual journey as he grapples with the implications of Foucault's work and its relevance to his own anthropological research.
The book begins by examining the initial encounter between cultural anthropology and Foucault's concepts, emphasizing the stark differences between the two disciplines. Sahlins delves into the initial reactions of anthropologists to Foucault's ideas and how they gradually gained traction within the field. He also explores the broader consequences of Foucault's work and its profound impact on social theory.
Throughout the book, Sahlins offers a comprehensive analysis of Foucault's theories and their implications for anthropology. He delves into Foucault's notions of power, discourse, and the construction of knowledge, shedding light on their relevance to anthropological research. Sahlins critically reflects on the challenges and limitations of adopting Foucault's framework, highlighting the importance of a nuanced and context-aware approach in anthropological analysis.
Available on Audible
Furthermore, Sahlins addresses the criticisms that Foucault faced within the discipline of anthropology. While acknowledging the profound influence of Foucault's ideas, he also explores the resistance and controversy surrounding them. Sahlins provides a fair and balanced evaluation of the strengths and weaknesses of Foucault's contributions to the field.
In summary, "Waiting for Foucault, Still" offers a thought-provoking exploration of the relationship between anthropology and the ideas of Michel Foucault. Sahlins skillfully navigates the complexities of this relationship, providing readers with a nuanced understanding of Foucault's impact on the discipline. This book is indispensable for scholars, students, and anyone interested in the intersection of anthropology and social theory.
What are readers saying?
"Waiting for Foucault, Still" by Marshall Sahlins has received mixed feedback from readers. The book delves into the intricate connection between anthropology, history, and philosophy, particularly in relation to the ideas of French philosopher Michel Foucault.
Some reviewers found Sahlins' analysis and insights to be thought-provoking and engaging. They commended the author's profound comprehension of Foucault's theories and his ability to apply them to anthropological studies. These readers admired the book's academic rigor and its exploration of power dynamics, knowledge production, and the construction of truth. They also appreciated Sahlins' clear and accessible writing style, which made complex concepts easier to comprehend.
On the other hand, some readers felt that Sahlins excessively idolized Foucault, treating him as the sole authority on these subjects. They criticized the book for lacking a more balanced approach and failing to engage with alternative perspectives. These readers also found the writing style to be dense and convoluted, making it challenging to follow the author's arguments.
A common criticism of the book was its repetitive nature, with some readers feeling that Sahlins reiterated his points too frequently, unnecessarily lengthening the book. Additionally, some felt that the book could benefit from more concrete examples and case studies, rather than relying solely on theoretical discussions.
Despite receiving mixed reviews, readers agreed that "Waiting for Foucault, Still" offers valuable insights into the fields of anthropology, history, and philosophy, particularly for those familiar with Michel Foucault's work. Sahlins' book provides a comprehensive and thought-provoking examination of the intersections between these disciplines, although it does have limitations in terms of approach and writing style.
WaitingForFoucaultStill BookLovers Philosophy